“The market was saturated with that kind of story”: Eiichiro Oda Never Wanted Luffy to Share Goku’s Curse That Became Akira Toriyama’s Biggest Dragon Ball Criticism

The fundamental difference between Luffy and Goku which helped One Piece stand its ground.

Luffy and Goku

SUMMARY

  • Eiichiro Oda opened up about how he didnt want any normal protagonist but a plot where friendship was more important.
  • Thus he drew Luffy who turned out to be the opposite of the typical Shonen protagonist.
  • Luffy and Goku have different attitudes despite having the same goal.
Show More
Featured Video

Eiichiro Oda, the mastermind behind One Piece, launched his manga at a time when people idolized Akira Toriyama as the supreme leader of Shonen manga. Dragon Ball was still ruling over the hearts of people and crushing new manga ideas within weeks. Yet, One Piece managed to stand up to the pressure and succeed.

Advertisement

The author of One Piece finally opened up about why he thinks his series has received such a phenomenal response and how it stands out from the rest of the crowd.

Eiichiro Oda Wanted to Do Something Different with One Piece

Gear 5 Luffy in One Piece by Eiichiro Oda
Gear 5 Luffy in One Piece | Toei

In an interview with the New York Times, Eiichiro Oda opened up about his inspirations when he first began drawing manga and how he wanted to shape One Piece. The author revealed that he had wanted to be a mangaka since a young age, and always drew things that didn’t exist to get attention.

Advertisement

Next, the mangaka switches to talk about what it was like to compete in the manga industry.

There were plenty of heroes who fight the demons and save the world; the market was saturated with that kind of story. I wanted to do something different but relatable.

Indeed, the Shonen world is dominated by stories of righteous heroes who will do anything to save the world. Most of them are teens who are assigned a heavy duty of protecting the Earth against evil enemies, demons, aliens, or other opposing forces. Oda naturally wanted to go the other direction and created the world of One Piece with the carefree Luffy as the protagonist.

According to the author, he had a realization that he was helped by a lot of people to reach where he stood, and thus friendship became a central theme in One Piece.

Advertisement

Oda Did Not Want Luffy to Share Dragon Ball Goku’s Curse

Akira Toriyama's Dragon Ball
Kid Goku | Dragon Ball Toei

Eiichiro Oda further admits that he always knew he wanted to write a pirate manga, and thus drew a young boy who he could imagine in the role. Little did he know that this gangly boy would soon become a hero celebrated by millions of people.

The difference between One Piece and Dragon Ball still holds, especially when it comes to the protagonists. After Dragon Ball‘s popularity drowned everything else, mangakas kept trying to create something inspired by it and fans wanted to read more of their comfort series. Naturally, the market was saturated with heroes who would save the world at any cost.

In every Dragon Ball battle, the stakes are too high to be ignored. If Goku loses, devastating results like the destruction of planets, universes, and reality could take place. In every arc, the stakes are raised further and further and Goku has to save much more than a single planet.

Advertisement
Luffy Exhausted After Gear 5 | Toei Animation
Luffy Exhausted After Gear 5 | Toei Animation

On the other hand, One Piece has stories related to individuals sometimes and Luffy helps people simply because he can’t stand his friends getting insulted or trodden upon. Yes, Luffy did end up in the same situation as Goku, in terms of having to save the world. But he is still a very happy-go-lucky fellow who is solving one problem at a time.

While Goku seeks out battles and fights for fun, Luffy does not like whipping out his gears till it’s absolutely necessary. While Goku fights to save the Earth, Luffy wants to become the Pirate King. The fundamentals of the characters are different, despite their reaching the same goal.

You can read One Piece and Dragon Ball on Viz Media and watch the anime on Crunchyroll.

Advertisement
Avatar

Written by Aaheli Pradhan

Articles Published: 202

Aaheli is an anime content writer at FandomeWire. With four years of experience under her belt, she is a living, breathing encyclopedia for anime and manga. She believes in living a slow life, surrounded by incomplete art projects and her beloved cat.