“Tom, we knew what we were doing!”: Tom Hanks Had to Change a Crucial Aspect of Band of Brothers After a Real-Life Veteran Was Unhappy With Original Decision

One Band of Brothers episode underwent transformation thanks to the golden insight that the real-life Major Dick Winters gave Tom Hanks

tom hanks, band of brothers

SUMMARY

  • Band of Brothers is a World War II miniseries created by Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg, based on real-life experiences of soldiers from the Easy Company.
  • The real Major Dick Winters - played by Damian Lewis in the series - felt wronged by Hanks' rendition of the soldiers as ill-prepared veterans.
  • Hanks and Spielberg went beyond Stephen E. Ambrose's book to fetch the material, ensuring that they stayed loyal to its historical accuracy.
Show More
Featured Video

Created by two of the industry’s most proficient goliaths Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg, Band of Brothers is a haunting iteration of how one of the most courageous troupes of men survived the throes of the Second World War.

Advertisement
Band of Brothers
Band of Brothers | HBO

Based on Stephen E. Ambrose’s non-fiction book of the same name, the HBO miniseries documents the horrific tale of the 506th Regiment of the 101st Airborne Division, denominated the Easy Company. And the result was an Emmy-wining show that yielded war archives staggering enough to keep you up at night.

Tom Hanks Altered Band of Brothers to Do Justice to the Real-Life Soldiers  

Considering how the WWII miniseries is based on Ambrose’s research findings along with interviews with the real-life veterans of Easy Company, authenticity and precision were of the utmost importance for co-creator Tom Hanks. After all, they were going to chronicle the war-stricken lives of actual soldiers who’d been through the most atrocious dregs of hell and back on the battlefield.

Advertisement

On one episode of the Band of Brothers podcast, Hanks, 67, recollected a conversation he had with the real Major Dick Winters – portrayed by Billions‘ Damian Lewis in the series – during post-production wherein the paratrooper disapproved of the filmmaker’s rendition of things (via Cinema Blend).

Damian Lewis as Dick Winters in Band of Brothers
Damian Lewis as Major Richard Davis “Dick” Winters | HBO

What irked Winters the most was how the Easy Company of the US Army Airbourne Paratrooper Division came off as inept and unprepared in the Days of Days episode whereas the reality narrated a different story. The Saving Private Ryan star recalled what the veteran told him –

‘Tom, we knew what we were doing. We knew where we were. We knew what needed to get done. You have it looking like we haven’t even read the map correctly!’

Hanks, for his part, heeded Winters’ advice with complete sincerity, refusing to slander the lived experiences of gallant soldiers who risked their lives during World War II. “There isn’t anything that we’ve shot that can’t be moved, changed, altered,” the 2-time Oscar winner reassured the esteemed Major.

Advertisement

Band of Brothers Producers Nailed the Historical Accuracy

The material Ambrose had dug in while penning the annals of the parachute infantry company in the 101st Airborne Division was already extensively researched. But the show’s creators – both of whom also served as executive producers – went beyond the 1992 book and both Hanks and Steven Spielberg made sure of that.

The Captain Phillips star and Spielberg along with the production crew, immersed themselves in the lives and experiences of the heroic men who shed blood, sweat, and tears during the war, ensuring that the on-screen adaptation of Band of Brothers is as historically accurate as possible (via Deadline).

Tom Hanks
Tom Hanks in Saving Private Ryan | DreamWorks Pictures/Paramount Pictures

“The anecdotal details of behavior and procedure are more important than sticking to story-story-story. The overview of the story becomes one with the moments of character,” Hanks said. And that’s how you both make and preserve history.

Advertisement

Band of Brothers can be streamed on Max. 

Avatar

Written by Khushi Shah

Articles Published: 791

With a prolific knowledge of everything pop culture and a strong penchant for writing, Khushi has penned over 700 articles during her time as an author at FandomWire.
An abnormal psychology student and an fervent reader of dark fiction, her most trusted soldiers are coffee and a good book.