“Our Tarnished may just be the worst person alive…”: 1 Part of Elden Ring’s Shadow of the Erdtree Isn’t Painting Us as the Savior We Think We Are

Is this the dream players have been chasing all along in Elden Ring?

shadow of the erdtree

SUMMARY

  • Elden Ring Shadow of the Erdtree DLC was finally released last month.
  • Players come across Midra, the Lord of Frenzied Flame in the DLC.
  • Gamers have begun wondering about the protagonist's true character after the fight against Midra.
Show More
Featured Video

As all the players would agree, Elden Ring is a complicated game, something that FromSoftware and Hidetaka Miyazaki might have intended to do ever since the beginning but that does not help stop gamers from creating the wrong impression about some elements of the storyline.

Coming up with how our Tarnished Character might not just be the best person to be wandering The Lands Between and the Realm of Shadow, a player has expressed how he feels after beating a particular boss in the recent DLC.

Advertisement

Old Man in the Mansion – Players Wonder What Is the Tarnished’s Purpose in Elden Ring

×

In retrospect, there are a lot of questionable acts the tarnished commits throughout the playthrough of the game, but none has ever come to question like this one in recent times.

Posting on Elden Ring’s Reddit forum, a user has asked other players if there is any definite reason why the tarnished takes Midra, the Lord of the Frenzied Flame as an opponent, defeating him after invading Midra’s Manse in the Abyssal Woods. He is, after all, an old guy just ‘chilling alone’ in his house.

Advertisement
Is there a canonical reason why?
byu/Karrotyboi inEldenring

While there is not much one can say about what particular purpose Hidetaka Miyazaki had in mind while creating the main game and its recent Shadow of the Erdtree DLC, users in the comments section have given their thoughts on the topic, with some stating how it is our character’s mission to collect whatever power remains in the world.

Is there a canonical reason why?
byu/Karrotyboi inEldenring

Furthermore, with new revelations in the recent DLC, the guidance of the Greater Will comes into question as it is possible that not only the player, but even Queen Marika herself was following outdated guidance from the outer god.

Outdated Guidance – What Has Been Going On in Elden Ring?

A promotional picture for Elden Ring
We might have been following the wrong guidance all along. | Image Credit: FromSoftware

It was made clear from the very beginning how there is a huge timeline of events queued behind the present times before we arrive in The Lands Between. Spanning over 5000 years and written by George RR Martin, the story goes over the shattering of Elden Ring and all the demigods fighting against each other.

Advertisement

However, it is possible the very rule of Queen Marika and her quest to conquer the world was done while following outdated guidance from the Greater Will. Encountering Metyr, Mother of Fingers in the recent Shadow of the Erdtree DLC, players come to know how she has been driven crazy and stopped receiving communication from the outer god a long time ago.

While the new revelation fails to get much spotlight with all that has been going on with Miquella and his journey to ascend into godhood, it is ultimately a perspective-changing fact that could change how fans look at Elden Ring forever.

Have you ever wondered about the one true purpose of the Tarnished? Make sure to let us know about it in the comments below!

Advertisement
Aaditya Chugh

Written by Aaditya Chugh

Articles Published: 472

Aaditya Chugh is a Gaming Content Writer at FandomWire. With a passion for everything gaming, he's the one you turn to for the latest insights and reviews straight from the industry. Whether he's diving into timeless classics like the first ever Doom or staying up-to-date with the newest releases like Helldivers 2 and Stellar Blade, he provides whatever you might need to stay in the loop.