6 Most Controversial Oscar Decisions That Will Make Your Blood Boil for the Sheer Disrespect

These controversial winners will make you question the Academy Awards.

Here are the most controversial Oscar winners from the past!

SUMMARY

  • Here are the most controversial winners from the past that changed the Oscars event.
  • The list includes actors with scandals and acclaimed films snubbed by the award-giving body.
  • Despite the years, these winners remain the hot topic of debate within the film industry.
Show More
Featured Video

The Oscar Awards is almost here, and what better way to get ready for it than to reminisce about the most outrageous and shocking winning moments that happened in the past years.

Advertisement

While some names and titles are already taking up space and garnering unanimous votes, there will be controversial results that will go down in history, just like these Academy Award winners.

Will Smith

will smith king richard oscar
Will Smith in King Richard

The comedian-actor has always been a crowd favorite, and his Best Actor win for the biographical sports drama King Richard at the 94th Academy Awards in 2022 was supposed to be a glorious moment. But, just before he was announced as the winner, the infamous Oscar slap shocked the entire world.

Advertisement

The award-giving body was criticized for letting Will Smith receive his award and remain inside the theater after his scandalous encounter with host Chris Rock. He was given a 10-year ban from attending the event, though being announced as the winner after all that fiasco even made the event more shocking than ever.

Green Book

Peter Farrelly’s Green Book
Peter Farrelly’s Green Book

Peter Farrelly’s Green Book won the votes of the jury at the 91st Academy Awards, beating Alfonso Cuarón’s critically acclaimed project Roma for the Best Picture.

The latter received ten impressive nominations which made it a strong contender for the much-coveted category. The controversy lies in the Academy’s decision to snub Roma since it is a Netflix film.

Advertisement

Shakespeare in Love

john madden shakespeare in love
John Madden’s Shakespeare in Love

The 1999 Oscars event was marred with so much controversy after John Madden’s Shakespeare in Love effortlessly beat Steven Spielberg’s Saving Private Ryan for the Best Picture category.

The epic war film was a major frontrunner at the event after receiving eleven nominations, and its loss against Gwyneth Paltrow’s period romantic comedy became Oscar’s biggest upset. Industry pundits speculated that the movie’s victory was attributed to the awards campaign led by Harvey Weinstein.

The King’s Speech

tom hooper the king's speech
Tom Hooper’s The King’s Speech

David Fincher’s The Social Network was both a cult-classic favorite and critically acclaimed film, even earning an impressive 96% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, but its loss against Tom Hooper’s The King’s Speech for Best Picture and Best Director became the talk of the town at the 83rd Academy Awards.

Advertisement

The Social Network is considered one of the greatest movies of the 21st century, so choosing a historical drama over a relevant biographical film ended up creating a negative buzz within the Oscars.

Roman Polanski

roman polanski's the pianist
Roman Polanski’s The Pianist

Roman Polanksi has become a notorious name in Hollywood after he was accused of s*xual assault and statutory r*pe. Surprisingly, the Oscars still gave him a Best Director award for his work on The Pianist.

He was not able to attend the event since he already fled from the US. It was only in 2018 when the Academy expelled Polanski from his membership.

Advertisement

Robert Redford

robert redford’s ordinary people
Robert Redford’s Ordinary People

Martin Scorsese is a staple name in the Oscars, so it was a shocker when Raging Bull lost the Best Director award to Robert Redford’s Ordinary People. The win was a turning point in the latter’s career as it is a feature directorial debut.

Avatar

Written by Ariane Cruz

Articles Published: 1944

Ariane Cruz, Senior Content Writer. She has been contributing articles for FandomWire since 2021, mostly covering stories about geek pop culture. With a degree in Communication Arts, she has an in-depth knowledge of print and broadcast journalism. Her other works can also be seen on Screen Rant and CBR.