Amidst the rugged beauty of the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, where family ties are as tangled as barbed wire, Beth Dutton, portrayed by Kelly Reilly, emerges as the most fiery and formidable rebel in the Paramount series. No, we can never forget the tempestuous tornado that is, Beth, outshining her brothers Jamie, Kayce, and the late Lee in her fierce independence and audacious spirit.
Straying from the pack, where her male siblings often tiptoe around their father, John Dutton, played by Hollywood’s stalwart, Kevin Costner, Beth blazes her own trail with a tongue as sharp as a cattle brand. A beloved and bemoaned figure rolled into one, she garners an eclectic posse of admirers and naysayers with each brash showdown.
Regardless, discontent rustles like dry leaves among the fans who sense déjà vu in every Beth Dutton scene—a familiar rehash with fresh lipstick but the same old script. The notorious bar incidents have fans reeling with a blend of admiration and exhaustion. Are we merely witnessing a carousel of confrontations, tirelessly rotating with the same old merry-go-round of expletives?
Kelly Reilly Deserves Better: The Pitfalls of Taylor Sheridan’s Characterization of Beth Dutton
Kelly Reilly’s fierce Beth Dutton is unquestionably the most outspoken and audacious heir of John Dutton in the hit show Yellowstone. Amongst John’s children, Beth stands out as a wild card compared to her brothers Jamie, Kayce, and Lee. While the boys tend to toe the line with their father, Beth has no reservations about speaking her mind and challenging John’s authority.
This boldness has garnered her a mix of admirers and detractors, depending on how one perceives her character. However, some fans have started to feel a sense of déjà vu when it comes to Beth’s scenes. They claim that every encounter she has, particularly in those bar scenes, seems like a recycled script where a man approaches her, she effortlessly shuts him down with cutting remarks, and the cycle repeats itself.
These fans lament the lack of character development and growth in Beth, making her interactions predictable and stale.
One fan expressed their frustration by stating:
Everythign about Beth is getting old
byu/dhsutherland inYellowstonePN
Similar feelings were expressed by another fan, who said, the bar scene was just a rehash of what we’ve seen before.
Comment
byu/dhsutherland from discussion
inYellowstonePN
Following up on the fan discussion, some fans thought that Beth had an easy time in the bar scene because they thought the character was already very predictable at this point in Yellowstone. Well, many fans are itching for a change in Beth’s storyline and an end to her encounters being the same.
While Beth’s fiery personality undoubtedly adds a spark to the show, it’s essential for her character to evolve and surprise viewers instead of treading the same well-worn path. Even Reilly, who seems to have noticed the growing resentment as well, is unable to defend Taylor Sheridan’s portrayal of her as the worst-written character (see Us Weekly).
Kelly Reilly Prepares for Her Role in the Yellowstone Spinoff?
After the conclusion of Yellowstone, can the spirit of the Dutton family’s saga be far behind? The answer, thrillingly, is a resounding no. The highly anticipated Yellowstone spinoff comes bearing the gift of continuity and nostalgia, with a dash of fresh intrigue.
Amidst fervor and speculation, the latest whispers from Puck reveal a reunion that will delight fans to their core: three beloved pillars of Yellowstone, Cole Hauser, Kelly Reilly, and Luke Grimes, are on the cusp of finalizing their returns as the indomitable Rip Wheeler, fiery Beth Dutton, and introspective Kayce Dutton, respectively.
Announced in 2023, and building upon the unforeseen departure of Kevin Costner, Taylor Sheridan’s creative masterstroke ensures the Dutton legacy thrives, potentially expanding star power to align with the show’s vision.
As the captivating mosaic that is the Dutton family saga continues to unfold in Yellowstone, anticipation crackles in the air with the approach of Season 5’s second part, set to grace our screens on November 10, 2024.
There’s an electrifying curiosity swirling around the fiery Beth Dutton—will her character arc ignite a new wave of admiration from viewers, or will she remain a beacon of relentless defiance?
With the series’ richly woven storylines, we can’t deny that Yellowstone never fails to surprise us, masterfully holding a mirror to the complexities of family, power, and the untamed spirit of the American West.
Stream Yellowstone on Paramount+.
