“There was no way the story could end satisfyingly”: Attack on Titan Fans Knew the Exact Moment Hajime Isayama ‘Messed Up’ the Story for No Return That Divided the Fandom Forever

Attack on Titan fans identify the moment Hajime Isayama's story took a divisive turn, leading to its controversial ending and its impact on fandom.

attack on titan

SUMMARY

  • Fans pinpoint 'The Rumbling' as the narrative turning point where Hajime Isayama's story became irretrievably controversial.
  • The series' conclusion left many questions unanswered, sparking widespread debate and speculation within the fandom.
  • Despite divided opinions on the ending, Attack on Titan's legacy remains firmly established in the anime and manga industry.
Show More
Featured Video

Unlike any other manga in the popular Shonen tropes, Attack on Titan‘s ending created controversial debates. The series creator, Hajime Isayama, had to rewrite the ending to make it better for viewers. Initially, Eren Yeager was seen fighting for humanity and saving lives. But in the latter part, his personality totally changes by going against humanity and initiating the devasting Rumbling.

Advertisement
A scene rom Attack on Titan where Eren formed into the Founding Titan
A scene where Eren formed into the Founding Titan | Credit: MAPPA Studio

It sparked discussion about the direction of the narrative which took a bend in its final arc. The Attack on Titan community marked a specific point from chapter 130 or before, which many believed was the turning point for the series. This contentious moment of turning ultimately led to a disharmonious finale. Due to the series’ argumentative ending its fandom was split in half.

A World-Shattering Decision of Attack on Titan’s Rumbling

The Devastating Nature of the Rumbling
The Devastating Nature of the Rumbling | Credit: MAPPA Studio

The establishment of “The Rumbling,” a devastating event initiated by Eren Yeager was the starting point from which he couldn’t turn back. This had been identified by fans as a point in the narrative where Hajime Isayama stained himself into a corner. Though the scenario was thrilling, it presented a challenge for a satisfactory completion.

Advertisement
Comment
byu/Zer0_Wing from discussion
inCharacterRant
Comment
byu/Zer0_Wing from discussion
inCharacterRant

Some of the series fanbase argued that once Eren set foot on this path, it was inevitable for him to return. There was a dilemma revolving around it. If he succeeded, it would make the arcs’ characters meaningless. But if he failed, it would make his own character development and the fate of Paradis unsettled.

Some fans felt sorry for Eren’s miserable attempt to save his homeland. While others were petrified by the mass-scale destruction he was willing to take. Eren’s character mirrored the real-world discussion about nationalism and the cost of survival. The story dramatically shifted from a localized conflict to a Rumbling which brought a global catastrophe.

Fractured Fandom’s Unanswered Questions for the Narrative Loose End

Founding Titan form of Eren Yeager
Founding Titan form of Eren Yeager | Credit: MAPPA Studio

The ending of Attack on Titan had left its fandom in a state of controversial affairs. Although the series has already ended, the discussion surrounding its finale still revolves around the whole community. Fans remain unsatisfied with the unanswered questions left in the series’ ending.

Advertisement

Particularly pointing to Historia’s character which seemed to lose its focus in the latter part of the narrative. Also, the motivating force behind Eren’s action and the true nature of Titan Power have been dissolved to the ground by its conclusion. It just became a subject of fan speculation and discussion.

Even though Attack on Titan had a controversial ending, it undeniably left a footprint on the anime and manga industry. It consistently provoked its audience’s thoughts and emotions in the same proportionate. Also, fan-made projects like AoT no Requiem gained significant attention. It showcased how the series has inspired its audiences.

Attack on Titan is available to watch on Crunchyroll as of 19th August 2024.

Advertisement
Avatar

Written by Akihito Chakma

Articles Published: 81

Holding a Master's degree in English, Akihito is a dedicated Content Writer at FandomWire. He has a keen focus on the ongoing anime series, classic series and new releases. With his passion for anime and writing skills, Akihito keeps fans informed and entertained through his work.