Ever since Disney acquired the space-opera franchise created by George Lucas, Star Wars, it has been expanding upon the lore and trying to develop its own stories within the larger universe. But so far, it has failed to achieve the grandeur and reverence that the original franchise had. And the latest addition to its crown jewel of disappointments is The Acolyte.
Made with the purpose of exploring the unexplored lores of the Star Wars universe, the show, throughout its run, battled a sea of negative criticism and online hate. Yet, despite the cancelation of its second season, fans are refusing to back down, instead criticizing the ‘fans’ who made the cancelation happen, forgetting to address the massive budget the show had.
Star Wars Fans Not Happy With The Acolyte Getting Canceled After One Season
It is not a fact unknown that Disney has so far failed to bring a Star Wars project that fans have loved the same way they have loved the original George Lucas-created franchise. So while they have often shown their ire towards Disney’s Star Wars projects, none have received the anger and hate that Leslye Headland’s The Acolyte has received.
As a result, it wasn’t a surprise when it was announced that the series would not be renewed for a second season (via THR), thus potentially ending the conundrum of cliffhangers and unexplored plotholes it left open. However, hard-core Star Wars fans, who were not offended by the fact that the show was more of an origin story, are not satisfied.
Instead, they have directed their anger towards the many social media hate campaigns that prompted the cancelation of The Acolyte. As the news went viral, this is what many of them had to say:
Reminder that people hated the first two seasons of the clone wars, yet it got 7 seasons and is beloved because of those later seasons. People didn’t like rebels season 1 and now it has 4 seasons. Y’all don’t give shows time to find their footing anymore
— rachelrobinsonsupernova (@UniquaJohn) August 20, 2024
unbelievably sad. the show was only getting better but these cunt review bombers destroyed what could have been a start to an interesting storyline with the dark side in focus. was looking forward to see more of Manny Jacinto.. 💔💔
— prick parker (@nycpudding) August 20, 2024
Blame the stupid “fans” who started criticizing the show without even watching first! The series was great and it was cancelled because we don’t have much true Star Wars fans around there…
— ~🦊💛 Tails and Nine worshiper 💛🦊~ (@Henriqu45242533) August 20, 2024
This is so beyond disappointing, the first show that had me really excited about the future of SW in a long time and now what? I'm so sick of this fandom's close mindedness
— Aoife (@aoifeeod) August 20, 2024
sad that it was canceled. it did have bad writing but the concept was new and engaging and manny jacinto was one of the best villains of SW yet. changing the showrunner could have fixed the issue. fans should really learn to give space and stop the hate campaigns
— Wolowitz Coefficient (@inquilabaurkya) August 20, 2024
While it is true the show’s cancellation can be because of the many hate campaigns against it and the incoherent and bad writing it had, Star Wars fans seem to forget the massive budget the show had. One of the most expensive shows of all time, fans fail to acknowledge the fact that with a show as expensive as The Acolyte, the returns need to be there as well.
The Acolyte’s Cancelation Has More to Do with Its Budget and Viewership Than Fan Hate
For a show containing an entirely original storyline, set in the past and with no direct connection to the original Skywalker lore, The Acolyte was already poised to not receive the same level of love as other Star Wars projects. The show introduced several new characters (only to kill some of them), but its ‘bad pacing and writing’, and countless unanswered plotholes also made it subject to immense hate from certain factions of the fandom.
However, ultimately, it was The Acolyte’s huge production budget and lack of significant viewership that undeniably played a huge role in its cancelation. Made against a budget of more or less $180 million (via NY Times), neither the length nor the quality of the show justifies such a huge budget.
Compared to other Star Wars shows by Disney, its budget seems unnecessarily huge given the reception it received. Obi-Wan Kenobi took a record $90 million to produce (via EpicStream), while others like Ahsoka had a $100+ million budget (via Dexerto), The Book of Boba Fett‘s first season cost around $15 million per episode, The Mandalorian’s 16-episodes+ cost about $360 million (via MovieWeb), and the franchise’s highest-rated series, Andor’s first season costed a record-breaking $250 (via THR).
Furthermore, the show is also one of the least-watched Disney’s Star Wars series (via Luminate). Even though it got off to a nice start when it was first released, having a chart-topping 4.8 million views, the show’s viewership fell with each episode, ultimately dropping out of the Top 10 on Nielson’s Top 10 before landing at the last place after its finale release (via Deadline).
Costing almost $200 million to produce, such a low viewership is undeniably the reason why Disney did not renew the show for a second season. Even though some fans are not happy, ultimately it is the ‘money’ that decides the fate of these projects.
The Acolyte Season 1 can be streamed on Disney+.
