“I just think Beth does it to purposefully make him uncomfortable”: Even Yellowstone Fans are Confused With Taylor Sheridan’s Borderline Incestuous Storyline With Beth and Jamie That’s Hard to Defend

The Beth-Jamie relationship in Yellowstone has sparked debate, with many finding its unsettling dynamics skirting dangerously close to incestuous.

Taylor Sheridan, Beth and Jamie

SUMMARY

  • Beth and Jamie Dutton's rivalry is like mixing high-octane gasoline with fireworks—volatile, explosive, and not for the faint-hearted.
  • But some viewers see their interactions as a hot mess of romantic tension.
  • According to Taylor Sheridan, Beth is the toughest cookie in Yellowstone, tossing out rejection and defiance with flair.
Show More
Featured Video

If you think the relationship with your sibling is on the fritz, just take a gander at Beth and Jamie’s drama—it’s like sibling rivalry on steroids! Yes, it’s really amusing how some good old sibling rivalry never really dies, especially in the wild, wild world of Yellowstone. Beth Dutton’s enjoyment of provoking her brother Jamie in the series is a prime example of how deep-seated trauma, complex personalities, and unresolved childhood grievances can brew a potent cocktail of familial animosity.

Advertisement
Beth and Jamie Dutton's rivalry is like mixing high-octane gasoline with fireworks—volatile, explosive, and not for the faint-hearted.
Beth Dutton and Jamie Dutton in Yellowstone | Credit: Paramount Network

But why does Beth take such palpable pleasure in tormenting Jamie? With an intricate web of their intertwined pasts (and, of course, contrasting personas), Beth’s actions make a rather twisted sense. It’s like watching a high-stakes chess game fueled by fiery emotions where every jab she makes lacks brotherly love but is laden with psychological warfare.

Interestingly, this contentious relationship stirs the pot with fans, some of whom see hints of a ‘borderline incestuous storyline’ driven by s*xual tension, which adds another perplexing layer to their interactions.

Advertisement

Yellowstone: The Strange Connection Between Beth & Jamie Is Too Much For Fans

Beth and Jamie’s relationship in Yellowstone– Their backstory is like a pot of boiling stew, simmering with unresolved issues and seasoned with trauma. The death of their mother has left a sour taste in both their mouths, and Beth’s deep-seated resentment towards Jamie is a major ingredient in their ongoing spat. She’s got a bone to pick with him and isn’t afraid to use it.

But hold onto your hat, because things get even more tangled. Fans are scratching their chins over Taylor Sheridan’s storyline, which seems to blur the lines between sibling rivalry and something that raises more than a few eyebrows. Some viewers feel like there’s a hint of romantic tension in their interactions—like watching a slow-motion car crash where you can’t look away.

But some viewers see their interactions as a hot mess of romantic tension.
Beth Dutton and Jamie Dutton in Yellowstone | Credit: Paramount Network

One fan has cut right to the chase, saying their relationship seems more like a steamy romance novel than a family drama. They joked that every time Beth and Jamie interact, it feels like they’re one step away from a full-blown, romantic scene:

Advertisement
Beth and Jamie’s Weird Relationship
byu/MyCrazyXX inYellowstonePN

Another fan chimed in with a more down-to-earth take, suggesting that Beth’s antics are all about making Jamie squirm. They reckon Kelly Reilly’s character has intentionally pushed her buttons because she just doesn’t care what anyone thinks, and frankly, she’s got no qualms about making him uncomfortable.

Comment
byu/MyCrazyXX from discussion
inYellowstonePN

Indeed, Beth and Jamie’s relationship is like a high-stakes poker game, where every move and gesture carries a hidden meaning. Whether it’s trauma, dominance, or something a bit more confusing, their interactions keep viewers on the edge of their seats.

Let’s see what others are saying:

Advertisement
Comment
byu/MyCrazyXX from discussion
inYellowstonePN
Comment
byu/MyCrazyXX from discussion
inYellowstonePN
Comment
byu/MyCrazyXX from discussion
inYellowstonePN

So, while Beth and Jamie’s relationship might be a head-scratcher for some, it’s certainly never dull. 

Taylor Sheridan Weighs In: Beth Dutton is the Toughest Character in Yellowstone

Beth Dutton might not win any awards for subtlety in Yellowstone but she certainly knows how to keep things spicy. From the get-go, Beth’s tactics are anything but lukewarm. The first season shows her unapologetic approach as she tackles every challenge head-on, proving that when it comes to handling trouble, she’s all gas and no brakes.

According to Taylor Sheridan, Beth is the toughest cookie in Yellowstone, tossing out rejection and defiance with flair.
Kelly Reilly as Beth Dutton | Credit: Paramount Network

In a chat with Deadline, Taylor Sheridan shed light on Kelly Reilly’s character, saying:

Advertisement

You know, the toughest person on that show is Beth [played by Kelly Reilly].

Sheridan’s comment highlights Beth’s unmistakable rejection of a smarmy cowboy, exhibiting her fearless nature and no-nonsense attitude. A Vulture review aptly noted, “Kelly Reilly is giving her all to this part” underscoring how Beth’s sharp retorts are delivered with precision and flair.

The series made its debut on Paramount in the summer of 2018 with ratings that were decent but not scintillating (Metacritic).

Fast forward to Season 4, and the show had turned into a juggernaut, with the premiere drawing a staggering 12.7 million viewers—a whopping 66% boost from the Season 3 debut (via Deadline). The show had solidified its spot as one of the most-watched series, proving that Beth Dutton’s brand of toughness is just what viewers crave!

Advertisement

Yellowstone Season 5’s second part will be available on November 10, 2024.

Stream Yellowstone on Paramount+.

Avatar

Written by Siddhika Prajapati

Articles Published: 1932

Between everyday normalities and supernatural abnormalities, Siddhika Prajapati finds the story in everything. Literature Honors Graduate and Post-Graduated in Journalism (from Delhi University), her undying need to deduce the extraordinary out of simplicity makes her a vibrant storyteller.

Serving as a Senior Entertainment Writer at Fandom Wire and having written over 1900 pieces, Siddhika has also worked with multiple clients and projects over the years, including Indian Express, India Today, and Outlook Group.

Who knows, maybe your next favorite persona on the screen will be crafted by her.