“Except no more old men with women their daughters’ age”: Taylor Sheridan Can Still Give Justice to Kevin Costner’s John Dutton in a Spin-Off With 1 Actor That is Waiting to Explode 

Taylor Sheridan eyes a fresh Yellowstone spin-off featuring a young John Dutton, promising new energy and leaving old tropes behind.

kevin costner’s john dutton, taylor sheridan

SUMMARY

  • Taylor Sheridan considers a Yellowstone spin-off focused on a young John Dutton, bringing a fresh perspective to the series.
  • Fans hope for fewer age-inappropriate relationships and more character development in future Yellowstone spin-offs.
  • Josh Lucas, who played young John Dutton, is eager to return for a spin-off exploring John's past and legacy.
Show More
Featured Video

When it comes to Taylor Sheridan’s Yellowstone, we’ve seen enough of old men chasing after women half their age—let’s mix it up, shall we? While Kevin Costner’s John Dutton has already solidified his place as the rugged patriarch, there’s a fresh opportunity brewing. Picture this: a spin-off that gives Dutton the justice he deserves, minus the tired tropes, and introduces a new face ready to blow the audience away. 

Advertisement
Taylor Sheridan
Taylor Sheridan in Yellowstone | image credit: Paramount Network

With one actor just waiting to break out and light up the screen, Sheridan’s next move could be the perfect blend of legacy and fresh energy. And who says only the old dogs get all the action? Sometimes, it’s the young pups that steal the show.

Taylor Sheridan’s Next Move: A Young John Dutton Spin-Off with a Shocking Twist?

Josh Lucas as young John Dutton
Josh Lucas as young John Dutton | Paramount Pictures

Taylor Sheridan ain’t done with Kevin Costner’s John Dutton just yet. As Yellowstone rides into its final sunset, there’s buzz about a spin-off that could reignite the Dutton saga. Picture this: a young John Dutton series that kicks off with a dramatic scene—older John bleeding out on the ground, a mystery shooter (or stabber) nowhere to be found.

Advertisement

John’s life flashes before his eyes, episode by episode, memory by memory. We get a front-row seat to his wild past and the choices that shaped him. And just when you think the dust has settled, bam—a shocking reveal of who took John down. Perfect for Sheridan’s brand of storytelling, right?

Josh Lucas, who portrayed young John Dutton, is eager to return. On SiriusXM’s The Spotlight with Jessica Shaw, Lucas shared his hope to saddle up again, saying (via EW):

You know, I sure hope so! I think so. I asked [series creator Taylor Sheridan] a while back, I sent him a text… because I did genuinely want to thank him for the experience, because I love being there. I love being out on those horses. I love being on that land.

And let’s face it—fans are ready for a fresh take, free from the cringe-worthy scenes of older Dutton with women half his age. As one fan put it, “Except no more old men with women their daughters’ age.”

Advertisement

Comment
byu/Significant-Sand9629 from discussion
inYellowstonePN

With Yellowstone’s final season dropping in November 2024 and two new spin-offs on deck, Sheridan’s all about leaving us wanting more. A series that starts with a dying John Dutton and ends with a jaw-dropping reveal? That’s how you keep folks hooked.

So, gear up for a ride where Sheridan’s signature storytelling meets a respectful tribute to John Dutton’s legacy.

Advertisement

Fans Torn Over Taylor Sheridan’s Bold Plans for Yellowstone: A Fresh Twist or Another Misstep?

Josh Lucas plays the younger version of Kevin Costner's Josh Dutton in Yellowstone
Josh Lucas plays the younger version of Kevin Costner’s Josh Dutton in Yellowstone | Paramount Pictures

Fans are buzzing about Taylor Sheridan’s plans to give Yellowstone a fresh twist. They’re excited to see Sheridan breathe new life into the series and explore John’s backstory. But not everyone’s on board with this idea. They argue that Yellowstone’s already gone off-rails, morphing from a gripping drama into a full-blown soap opera. 

Comment
byu/Significant-Sand9629 from discussion
inYellowstonePN

Comment
byu/Significant-Sand9629 from discussion
inYellowstonePN

Advertisement

Comment
byu/Significant-Sand9629 from discussion
inYellowstonePN

Comment
byu/Significant-Sand9629 from discussion
inYellowstonePN

Comment
byu/Significant-Sand9629 from discussion
inYellowstonePN

Advertisement

Comment
byu/Significant-Sand9629 from discussion
inYellowstonePN

Fans are skeptical about any new spin-offs or prequels, hoping for a finale that actually makes sense and gives the show a fitting end. Criticism is mounting, but Sheridan seems ready to surprise everyone—one last time.

Watch Yellowstone on Spectrum & Apple TV.

Advertisement
Avatar

Written by Heena Singh

Articles Published: 231

Heena Singh is a writer at FandomWire, spent the last two years making waves in entertainment journalism. With a knack for digging up blockbuster celebrity scoops and an uncanny nose for the latest buzz, Heena’s articles bring a fresh and fun perspective to life. When she’s not conquering writing challenges, you’ll find her curled up in bed, peacefully sleeping.