“It doesn’t represent the total experience”: Dark Souls 3 Beta Testing Showed Some Critical Errors Hidetaka Miyazaki Had To Correct With Fan Feedback

FromSoftware's reputation may be legendary, but even they're not immune to criticism.

"It doesn't represent the total experience": Dark Souls 3 Beta Testing Showed Some Critical Errors Hidetaka Miyazaki Had To Correct With Fan Feedback

SUMMARY

  • Dark Souls 3's network beta helped FromSoftware polish the game before release.
  • Players worried the beta felt too familiar, lacking the series' signature surprises.
  • Game director Hidetaka Miyazaki addressed these concerns, assuring fans the beta was for testing core mechanics and the full game would deliver new experiences.
Show More
Featured Video

Dark Souls 3 may have been the last in the franchise, but series mastermind Hidetaka Miyazaki made sure to release it in as polished a state as possible, with a network beta of the game to gauge player feedback. In an industry infamous for releasing games in half-baked states, FromSoftware’s commitment to quality is laudable.

Advertisement

However, the beta ignited concerns, particularly among series veterans, about the game’s direction. How did Miyazaki react to the beta’s perceived shortcomings, and how were they addressed by FromSoftware? Let’s find out.

Dark Souls 3 Beta Met With Mixed Reactions

The beta made many fans feel that the game wasn't innovating enough. Image credit: FromSoftware
The beta made many fans feel that the game wasn’t innovating enough. Image credit: FromSoftware

In an interview with GameSpot, the FromSoftware president and Dark Souls director shed light on the feedback they received from the Dark Souls 3‘s beta. The interview finds him fresh off audio work, highlighting his continued hands-on approach to the game.

Advertisement

The beta proved to be a bit contentious as players, including the interviewer, expressed a sense of disorientation. The core mechanics, difficulty curve, and even the level design all felt a bit too familiar in the beta. The exhilarating sense of discovery intrinsic to Souls games seemed absent.

This led to the notion that DS3 was simply retreading the familiar territory established by its predecessors, rather than being a brand-new, innovative experience that stands out.

Advertisement

FromSoftware’s Addressal Of The Complaints

Miyazaki said that the beta was a vertical slice; not indicative of the full experience. Image credit: NY Times
Miyazaki said that the beta was a vertical slice; not indicative of the full experience. Image credit: NY Times

Miyazaki acknowledged these concerns head-on, explaining that the beta content was strategically chosen. It wasn’t meant to showcase the full breadth of the game. Instead, it served as a test bed for core mechanics and online multiplayer functionality.

Balance adjustments and bug fixes based on this beta data were crucial for the final product. Miyazaki assured fans that the familiar elements encountered in the beta wouldn’t define the entire experience.

Advertisement

The true surprises, the challenging encounters, and the signature fragmented storytelling expected from a Souls title were indeed all present in the full game.

The true Dark Souls 3 experience was indeed glorious. Image credit: FromSoftware
The true Dark Souls 3 experience was indeed glorious. Image credit: FromSoftware

The interview demonstrated the tightrope walk that not only Miyazaki, but the entire games industry, has to perform – balancing fan expectations with creative evolution. The DS3 beta was met with lukewarm reception, but it still turned out to be a satisfying conclusion to the series.

Advertisement

One thing’s for certain, though. With Miyazaki at the helm, the chances of FromSoftware delivering a stale, predictable experience are near-impossible. Their legacy is built on defying expectations and pushing players to the limits of their skills. The beta was a necessary step towards ensuring a refined foundation for the true Dark Souls 3 experience.

Avatar

Written by Viraaj Bhatnagar

Articles Published: 205

A lifelong gamer, lover of cars, and Master's student of Automotive Journalism, Viraaj Bhatnagar is a gaming writer at FandomWire who aims to be one of the greats. When he's not hunched over on his laptop typing out copy, he can be found lapping circuits in Gran Turismo or slaying draugr in God of War.