“I’m just puzzled…”: Gears of War Fans Still Don’t Understand Why Gears 5 Gave Us a Franchise First Feature in the Worst Place

It is anyone's guess why The Coalition chose to end Gears 5 this way.

gears of war, gears 5

SUMMARY

  • Gears 5 released in 2019, the second game to feature JD, Kait and Del.
  • While it was looked down upon by hardcore fans, some enjoyed it.
  • The ones who liked the game still wonder why the ending was so heartbreaking and asked the player to make an incredibly difficult choice.
Show More
Featured Video

Gears of War is a series associated with the Xbox brand. There haven’t been a lot of titles for Microsoft that have stood out and attracted fans as much as the series.

Advertisement

However, most series fans agree that its quality and popularity plummeted after the first three games. So much so that the last game in the series, released in 2019, is considered one of the worst, if not the worst, games in the series.

Spoilers for Gears 5 ahead:

Advertisement

Gears of War 5’s Ending Has Left Fans Confused 5 Years Later, Too

×

After Judgement, the beginning of the end for Xbox’s premier third-person shooter series looked inevitable. Shortly after, The Coalition presented Gears of War: Ultimate Edition, a remaster of the first game. Unfortunately, every installment in the series since then has been a letdown for most fans.

However, the ones who enjoyed the new beginning with a storyline involving Kait, JD, and Del were left dumbfounded after the ending of Gears 5. Even in 2024, 5 years later, fans are confused about why the team deemed it fit to choose only one out of Kait’s two companions:

Posts from the gearsofwar
community on Reddit

Strangely, until the last game in the series, there hadn’t been an option to save a character at another’s cost. Hence, it makes for a valid question for fans. A fan suggested that it was incredibly similar to the mechanics put into games by developers like Telltale Studios:

Advertisement
Comment
byu/Jamacianjujubeans from discussion
inGearsOfWar

While it was metaphorically cruel of the writing team to let the player choose between two pivotal characters, their decision with the next game only made things worse for people looking forward to closure.

Gears of War E-Day Seems Great, but Now That It’s Confirmed, There’s a Problem

Marcus Fenix and Dominic Santiago in a screenshot from Gears of War E-Day.
Xbox announced the latest game, a prequel to the first game, set 14 years before the first game. Image Credits: Xbox Game Studios.

It is common knowledge among Gears of War series fans that the original trilogy was excellent and represented the golden era for the franchise. That is precisely why E-Day‘s announcement during Xbox Game Showcase 2024 was incredibly well-received, especially by fans of the original games.

Looking at Marcus Fenix and Dominic Santiago in their prime was a visual delight for fans. However, fans expecting The Coalition to complete the Kait/ JD trilogy after leaving it on a cliffhanger were understandably gutted.

Advertisement

But again, it could’ve been that Gears of War: E-Day was used as a bargaining chip to save the franchise from sinking into oblivion. Overall, suffice it to say there is no definite release timeline for the upcoming game, so the Gears of War 6‘s future remains in flux.

What did you think of the Gears 5 ending? Who did you save? Are you looking forward to Gears of War: E-Day‘s release, or would you instead get closure on the Kait and JD storyline first? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!

Avatar

Written by Sparsh Jaimini

Articles Published: 462

Sparsh Jaimini Sharma is a video games enthusiast and a Games Writer. A true white-blooded Madridsta. He is often seen grinding away at EAFC 24's Ultimate team and learning to code when he is not writing. A Batman fan and Arkham Games connoisseur. He is the quintessential DC aficionado.