George Lucas Helped Create a Villain Cool Enough “To replace Darth Vader” He Himself Regrets Killing Off Too Early

George Lucas originally planned on killing off Darth Maul in the first prequel film despite the character being cool enough to rival Darth Vader's popularity.

george lucas, darth vader
credit: wikimedia commons/Justass

SUMMARY

  • George Lucas' Star Wars franchise, includes the iconic villain Darth Vader, whose popularity is hard to rival but Lucas nearly found a replacement in Darth Maul.
  • In an interview, Lucas talked about creating Darth Maul for the prequels to have a similar presence to that of Vader in the original trilogy.
  • However, Lucas later regretted killing off Maul too soon and the character was eventually revived for Star Wars: The Clone Wars animated series.
Show More
Featured Video

George Lucas’ Star Wars franchise features several iconic villains, including Darth Vader, whose presence was integral to the success of the original trilogy of films. As a result, when Lucas decided to work on the prequel trilogy, he wanted to create an antagonistic force that could rival the on-screen presence of Vader.

Advertisement
Darth Maul in The Phantom Menace
Darth Maul was first introduced in 1999’s The Phantom Menace.

As a result, Lucas created the fan-favorite character of Darth Maul, who was introduced in the first prequel trilogy film. However, Maul was killed off unceremoniously at the end of the film. Nonetheless, Lucas eventually regretted the decision to kill off such a beloved and fascinating character. Here is what George Lucas has said about Darth Maul’s creation and the decision to kill him off.

George Lucas Talks Creating Darth Maul to Replace Darth Vader For the Star Wars Prequels

George Lucas returned to write and direct the first film in the prequel trilogy of Star Wars movies, with 1999’s The Phantom Menace. The film introduced the character of Darth Maul, with actor Ray Park physically playing the role and Peter Serafinowicz voicing him. Maul is the Sith apprentice of Palpatine.

Advertisement
george lucas amc
George Lucas reveals creating Darth Maul to replace Darth Vader in the prequels (Image via AMC)

Lucas spoke about the creation of Maul in an in-depth interview with Empire, explaining why fans were fascinated with the character and found him cool. He said:

“Obviously, everyone likes the villain better than they like the heroes, that’s sort of a tradition. And obviously, I was trying to make a villain who was sufficient to replace Darth Vader because Vader was such a great villain.”

Lucas added that initially, he planned to kill off Darth Maul during a battle with Obi-Wan, where the former falls down a pit. However, Lucas changed the scene to depict Maul getting cut in half so that the fans would be convinced that the character was permanently dead.

George Lucas Regretted Killing Off Darth Maul Too Soon and Planned to Revive Him

In the same interview with Empire, Lucas stated he wanted to make Maul’s death appear permanent as Palpatine searching for new apprentices was going to be a major plot point in the prequels. However, years later, Lucas would come to regret his decision to kill off Maul too soon, especially because of his fan-favorite status.

Advertisement
Darth Maul in Star Wars: The Clone Wars
Darth Maul was later revived for Star Wars: The Clone Wars

According to producer Henry Gilroy, Lucas originally planned to reveal that General Grievous was Darth Maul, who had survived being cut into half. However, this plan was soon abandoned. Nonetheless, Lucas’ regret over killing off Maul was evident when he instructed Dave Filoni to resurrect the character for Star Wars: The Clone Wars.

During an interview with Entertainment Weekly, Filoni revealed that Lucas had ordered him to revive Maul after he became fascinated with the character while developing Savage Opress for the animated series. Thus, Maul eventually returned first in The Clone Wars and later in Star Wars Rebels.

Lucas also planned on including Maul in his sequel trilogy before the Disney takeover forced him to abandon his plans. Nonetheless, Maul made his impending return to the Star Wars films with Solo: A Star Wars Story, appearing briefly as the head of the criminal syndicate Crimson Dawn.

Advertisement

Thus, it is safe to say that Lucas’ regret over killing off Maul too soon must have subsided by now.

The Star Wars films and other spin-offs are streaming on Disney+.

Pratik Handore

Written by Pratik Handore

Articles Published: 440

Pratik is a writer at FandomWire, with a content writing experience of five years. Although he has a Bachelors in Hospitality, his fascination with all things pop culture led him to writing articles on a variety of topics ranging from latest streaming releases to unheard movie trivia. When not writing, you can find him reading manga, or watching classic TV shows.