Rogue One: A Star Wars Story directed by Gareth Edwards is considered one of the best films in the space opera franchise. The film tells the story of a group of rebels, who steal the plans for the Death Star. It serves as a prequel to Star Wars: A New Hope, which started the franchise all the way back in 1977.
Rogue One emerged as a major critical and commercial success, attaining a fan-favorite status among the fandom. As a result, fans took to social media to discuss the film and argued what makes it so endearing and appealing. Most fans opined that the film avoided one pitfall that doomed other entries. Here is one major issue Rogue One avoided, which made it one of the best in the franchise.
Rogue One Dodged a Bullet That Many Other Star Wars Movies Fall For
Directed by Gareth Edwards, Rogue One follows a group of rebels who steal the plans for the Death Star, leading into the events of Star Wars: A New Hope. The film is considered one of the best entries in the franchise created by George Lucas, giving competition to the 1977 original helmed by the filmmaker.
Given the prequel film’s popularity, fans debated what makes Rogue One a great Star Wars movie on Reddit. In the Reddit thread, one fan argued that one of the film’s best-selling points is its lack of connection to the other entries in the franchise, particularly the lore established in them.
The main line of Star Wars movies primarily focuses on the conflict between the light and dark sides of the Force, harnessed by the Jedi and the Sith. However, one Reddit user pointed out how Rogue One avoids the pitfalls of the franchise’s complex lore, which makes it an endearing and memorable movie. The user wrote:
No Jedi centric plotline. It was from a soldier pov and we could see how it would be to face a jedi (sith) from their pov for the first time and it was incredible.
The user added how seeing the story unfold from the Jedi or Sith, who have superpowers and kill opponents by the dozen wasn’t compelling, a trend seen in other entries.
However, Rogue One kept things fresh by presenting the perspective of soldiers, particularly the Rebels who played a key role in overthrowing the Empire. The comment received support from other fans, proving that Rogue One was better off avoiding the complex lore-related plot points.
Fans Debate What Makes Rogue One Arguably the Best Star Wars Movie
In the same thread, fans debated about some of the other aspects of Rogue One that made the film arguably the best entry in the long-running franchise. One user argued that since the writers had a complete story and did not have to set up elements for future installments or answer questions from previous entries, the film turned out to be a great experience.
Similarly, another user stated that the film’s ending was another aspect that made Rogue One so memorable and effective in its storytelling. The user wrote:
The fact that the entire last few moments, All I was thinking was “okay, now how do they get out of here”, then they all died.
Meanwhile, another user explained how they felt the movie largely benefitted by treating the Empire as a competent threat unlike some of the other entries in the franchise.
They also argued that the competency of the Empire while dealing with the Rebels, neatly set the stakes for the movie, establishing the latter facing a behemoth opponent. Ultimately, Rogue One remains talked-about and revered among the fanbase because it set itself apart from the previous entries in multiple ways.
Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is streaming on Disney+.
