“He is a villain or simply a good person”: Unsolved Mystery Behind Shanks Collecting Devil Fruits Troubles One Piece Fans

One Piece fans are wondering whether Shanks is the good guy or the villain in the series as several theories arise about Evil Shanks.

"He is a villain or simply a good person": Unsolved Mystery Behind Shanks Collecting Devil Fruits Troubles One Piece Fans

SUMMARY

  • Shanks is one of the best characters from One Piece; however, theories suggest he might be evil.
  • One such theory explains the reason behind his collecting Devil Fruits: he is trying to keep them safe from evil’s reach.
  • Fans have quite a diverse reaction towards the sudden development of Shanks' character, as it's difficult to judge whether he is the good guy or a villain.
Show More
Featured Video

Shanks has been getting some new developments in One Piece, and the shift in his character has been a hot topic in the community for some time now. He became one of the most beloved characters in the series early on. He hasn’t appeared much in the series. However, all his appearances were highly anticipated.

Advertisement
Shanks from One Piece
Shanks from One Piece

As Luffy looks up to him, even his fans admire this enigmatic character. He was considered to be Luffy’s well-wisher however, with recent theories surfacing, it seems like that isn’t the case anymore. There are some theories that elaborate on evil Shanks and explain the reason behind his collecting Devil Fruits.

Also Read: “I think we did it well”: Eiichiro Oda Did Not Stand for Hate Against One Piece Live Action, Admitted Certain Differences in Series are Important

Advertisement

Why is Shanks collecting Devil Fruits in One Piece?

Shanks in One Piece
Red-Haired Shanks

Shanks is the only Yonko in One Piece without a Devil Fruit, which is quite a weird ordeal. Along with that, there isn’t even a single Devil Fruit user in his crew. We also know that Buggy is Roger’s crew’s only confirmed Devil Fruit user. However, it was hinted that he didn’t consume his Devil Fruit voluntarily and wasn’t happy that Shanks made him do it.

If we’re to keep Shanks’ situation side by side with what Blackbeard is doing, the theory suggests that he is doing the same thing but in a different way. His way is more stealing the Devil Fruit powers and using them for his crew members like Whitebeard, Absalom, and himself. Judging from this, the theory summarizes that Shanks collects the Devil Fruits to keep them in a safe place, minimizing their use for villainous activities.

Also Read: Wano Arc and One Piece Live Action’s Success has Eiichiro Oda Going All Out in Latest Manga Chapter, Making Things Even More Challenging for the Straw Hat Pirates

Advertisement

What were the fan reactions to this theory about Shanks?

Shanks and Luffy
Shanks and Luffy

A YouTube video discusses why Shanks might be collecting Devil Fruits on the Doronsworld channel. His take on this ordeal addresses that Shanks tries to keep the balance between piracy and stability.

Fans seemed to be having diverse reactions regarding whether they should judge Shanks’ character as a good guy or a villain. A user by the handle of Belwinuy commented, “Shanks is a very mysterious character we are not capable of understanding if he is a villain or simply a good person.”

Another person by the username Camino added under the video, “Imagine how much more broken these characters would be with a devil fruit, lol.”

Advertisement

What was particularly interesting is that a user by the name of Nakumezm1369 came up with their own theory, which started like this, “I’ve always liked to think that Shanks has been saving the Gum Gum No Mi to himself, but Luffy accidentally ate it so that’s actually why we see him shocked- not because he saw him ate A devil fruit, but because he saw him eat HIS devil fruit.”

They also delve further into the theory explaining why Shanks gave Luffy his hat. They also speculated that Shanks was “waiting this entire time so that the fruit could awaken itself inside Luffy.” As the time is correct, Luffy might be clashing with Shanks soon.

Also Read: “You can’t do that”: One Piece Director Was Strictly Against One Thing During the Breathtaking Action Sequences Including Zoro and Luffy

Advertisement
Avatar

Written by Archak

Articles Published: 295

Despite holding a degree in Chemistry Majors, Archak found himself as a Journalist. His love for anime and choccy milk is unmatched! When not writing, Archak can be found indulging with motorcycles. After all, four wheels move the body but two wheels move the soul!