“He is such a fine actor”. J.J. Abrams Has a Major Regret Over Casting Eric Bana in Star Trek That He Still Laments to This Day

Despite hitting it out of the park with the 2009 reboot, the one aspect that still bugs J.J. Abrams from 2009's Star Trek is Eric Bana's Nero.

J.J. Abrams Has a Major Regret Over Casting Eric Bana in Star Trek That He Still Laments to This Day

SUMMARY

  • J.J. Abrams succeeded in revamping Star Trek for the new generation despite not being a fan of the IP himself.
  • But despite making an acclaimed hit, he regrets not giving Eric Bana more material to work with in Star Trek.
  • While Abrams is certainly not a fan of Nero, who is only fueled by anger, Eric Bana had no problem with it, as he didn't want Nero to be humanized.
Show More
Featured Video

After putting the MI franchise back on track with the threequel in 2006, J.J. Abrams took Star Trek under his wings and revamped the IP for the new generation. While not a fan of the IP himself, which certainly didn’t sit well with the fandom, Abrams did manage to deliver one if not the best entry in the franchise since Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan with his 2009 reboot.

Advertisement

Upon its release, the film opened to critical acclaim and was a box-office success, But despite all of its accomplishments, the one thing that still bugs J.J. Abrams is the film’s villain, Eric Bana’s Nero.

Also read: J.J. Abrams Feels It Would Have Been a Mistake If Matt Damon Had Said Yes to ‘Star Trek’ Offer: “I went to Damon for the role of Kirk’s father”

Advertisement
J.J. Abrams' Star Trek (2009)
J.J. Abram’s Star Trek (2009)

J.J. Abrams Regrets Not Giving Eric Bana Enough Material to Work With

While many things went in the 2009 reboot’s favor, Eric Bana’s Nero just didn’t cut it for J.J. Abrams. Even though the casting for Star Trek couldn’t have been more perfect, as they resembled their older counterparts from the previous installments, Abrams stated Eric Bana’s acting chops were underutilized. In the movie, Bana played the revenge-bent villain, who is fueled by anger, and in an excerpt (via Slash Film), Abrams expressed regret over not giving Bana more material to work with.

“Our first ‘Star Trek’ movie was, if anything, an exercise in perfection of casting. April Webster and Alyssa Weisberg helped us find the absolutely perfect actors. I’m proud of its telling and humor, but of course only see what’s wrong with it. Among other things, I wish we had given Eric Bana a bit more to do other than be full of rage, given that he is such a fine actor.” 

Although the acclaimed release would’ve certainly benefited from witnessing more nuances in the character, Eric Bana had no complaints about playing the rageful villain.

Also read: J.J. Abrams’ ‘Lost’ Reportedly Consistently Humiliated People of Color on Set: “Nobody cares about these other characters”

Advertisement
Eric Bana | Star Trek
Eric Bana | Star Trek

Eric Bana Didn’t Want Nero to Be Overly Humanized

While the lack of depth certainly held Nero back, Eric Bana had no problem with what he got, stating that he didn’t want his character to be overly humanized and likable. But in an interview, the Troy Star did explain that he wanted his vengeance to be understandable, stating,

“I didn’t want to be overly humanized and overly likable, I just wanted his vengeance to be understandable. Just because I think it is more interesting for the audience. I never like it when we have to accept our villains just because they are villains.”

Also read” “He’s a show-off, man”: Idris Elba Hilariously Blamed Chris Pine For The Black Eye Mishap in Star Trek After Accidentally Punching Him in the Face

Eric Bana as Nero
Eric Bana as Nero

Although witnessing a madman driven by anger, who is bent on revenge wasn’t exactly something new, a strong performance from Bana ensured the character worked in the acclaimed reboot.

Advertisement

Star Trek is available to stream on Paramount Plus.

 

Advertisement
Avatar

Written by Santanu Roy

Articles Published: 1405

Santanu Roy is a film enthusiast with a deep love for the medium of animation while also being obsessed with The Everly Brothers, Billy Joel, and The Platters. Having expertise in everything related to Batman, Santanu spends most of his time watching and learning films, with Martin Scorsese and Park Chan-wook being his personal favorites. Apart from pursuing a degree in animation, he also possesses a deep fondness for narrative-driven games and is currently a writer at Fandomwire with over 1000 articles.