In the realm of cinema, directorial choices have the power to reshape the landscape of film history. One such example is the critically acclaimed film Joker, which delves into the origins of the iconic DC Comics character. Directed by Todd Phillips, Joker struck a chord with both audiences and critics, garnering numerous accolades and achieving great success at the box office. However, there was a time when the legendary Martin Scorsese was considered for the director’s chair.
As Joker continues to be celebrated and analyzed for years to come, one cannot help but wonder how Scorsese’s touch might have shaped the film differently. Nonetheless, his decision has given us a unique and haunting portrayal of the Joker that will forever hold its place in the pantheon of great cinema.
The Joker and Scorsese’s Cinematic Legacy
When approached with the opportunity to direct Joker, Martin Scorsese was undoubtedly drawn to exploring the psyche of one of the comic book lore’s most complex villains. The film’s script, written by Todd Phillips and Scott Silver, offered a gritty and grounded take on the character, aligning with Scorsese’s storytelling tendencies. Delving into the Joker’s origins and creating a character-driven narrative would have certainly appealed to Scorsese’s creative instincts.
Todd Phillips’ Joker undoubtedly borrows heavily from Martin Scorsese’s celebrated filmography, with clear inspiration drawn from classics such as Taxi Driver and The King of Comedy. While there were initial indications of Scorsese’s involvement as a producer for Joker, he ultimately didn’t receive credit in the final version of the film. When Phillips took over the project, Scorsese decided to step away and pursue other ventures, including his acclaimed film, The Irishman.
Martin Scorsese’s Decision to Pass on Directing Joker
In an illuminating interview with BBC, Martin Scorsese disclosed the reasons for declining the opportunity to direct Joker, attributing timing constraints and a belief that he wasn’t the right fit for the source material as the primary factors behind his decision. He said,
“I know the film very well. I know [director Todd Phillips] very well. My producer Emma Tillinger Koskoff produced it. I thought about it a lot over the last four years and decided I did not have the time for it. It was personal reasons why I didn’t get involved. But I know the script very well. It has real energy and Joaquin. You have remarkable work.”
“For me, ultimately, I don’t know if I will make the next step into developing into a comic book character. You follow? He develops into an abstraction. It doesn’t mean it’s bad art, it’s just not for me…The superhero films, as I’ve said, are another art form. They are not easy to make. There’s a lot of very talented people doing good work and a lot of young people really, really enjoy them.”
Although Martin Scorsese ultimately passed on directing Joker, the film found a capable helmsman in Todd Phillips. Phillips’ vision, combined with Joaquin Phoenix’s remarkable portrayal of the main character, breathed new life into comic book movies.
Source: Youtube
