Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark Would Have Looked a Lot Different If One ‘Batman Returns’ Actor Starred as Harrison Ford’s Side-kick

The Indiana Jones franchise would have looked vastly different if the studio had its way for iconic portrayal from the core cast

indiana jones and the raiders of the lost ark, batman returns

SUMMARY

  • The Indiana Jones franchise could have had a different portrayal of the beloved sidekick, altering the series’ dynamic and character chemistry.
  • Casting decisions for the sidekick role were influenced by scheduling conflicts and budget considerations, leading to a change from the original choice.
  • Harrison Ford’s casting as Indiana Jones was not initially planned, but his portrayal became iconic, contributing to the franchise’s global success and longevity.
Show More
Featured Video

In 1981, at the height of a cinematic rejuvenation for Hollywood, Steven Spielberg, in collaboration with George Lucas birthed the Indiana Jones franchise. Spanning across the genres of adventure, sci-fi, and adventure, the series quickly climbed up in popularity.

Advertisement

Famed for its iconic scenes, visual imagery, and well-gelled storyline, it quickly branched into popular culture with television series, novels, comics, video games, and theme park attractions based upon it.

Harrison Ford in character as Indiana Jones in Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom
Harrison Ford as Indiana Jones in Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom | Walt Disney Pictures

A major share of the success belonged to the leading man, Harrison Ford, and his acting prowess. The Han Solo actor brought with him his unique charisma that truly brought the fictional archaeologist to life. However, even he alone would not have catered to the storyline demands if not for his supporting cast, including his beloved sidekick Sallah.

Advertisement

Crafting a tale of mutual respect and unconditional friendship, the connection touched many hearts and sealed the deal for the franchise to grow. However, it would have looked very different if the filmmakers had their wishes fulfilled.

John Rhys-Davies was not the first choice to play Sallah

Sallah Mohammed Faisel el-Kahir played a pivotal role in the Indiana Jones franchise with his expertise and connections within the archeological community making him of indispensable value in-universe, whereas on-screen he helped bring out emotion and humor. Playing his part, John Rhys-Davies put his best foot forward and became synonymous with the role. However, at the start, the studio wanted Danny DeVito in his place.

John Rhys-Davies smiling as Sallah in Indiana Jones
John Rhys-Davies as Sallah in Indiana Jones | Walt Disney Entertainment

As per a detailed production history shared by All The Right Movies on X (formerly Twitter), Steven Spielberg settled for The Lords of the Kings actor after he successfully cleared the auditions. DeVito, on the other hand, had to turn down the role owing to a scheduling conflict with his ongoing TV show, Taxi. Moreover, a report by Empie also suggested that the actor’s quoted fees also led the studio to explore other options.

Advertisement

The Batman Returns actor has a vastly distinct stature and screen presence from Rhys-Davies and thus, would have made for a completely different canon that fans know and love now. While the latter brought a larger-than-life warmth to the character, the former might have leaned towards the cunning and street-smart aspects, considering the actor’s past experiences.

George Lucas initially denied Harrison Ford as Indiana Jones

A de-aged Harrison Ford in a still from Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny
A still from Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny | Walt Disney Entertainment

In a similar fashion to his on-screen sidekick, Harrison Ford was not the first choice to play the protagonist either, with both George Lucas and Steven Spielberg eyeing Tom Selleck for the role. However, the actor’s commitment to Magnum P.I. came in the way. In turn, not only did the star seal himself as the main man of the franchise for decades but also proved the Star Wars creator’s comments of him becoming his Bobby DeNiro false.

 Ford stayed in his role for five movies, with the last installment coming as recently as in 2023. However, unlike its predecessors, it failed to win over the audience. Disney’s poor marketing and several other reasons stood to blame. Regardless, the franchise has, as of now, a net worth of over a billion dollars and a cinematic value as one of the most recognized intellectual properties globally.

Advertisement
Avatar

Written by Imteshal Karim

Articles Published: 105

Bearing a penchant for writing in multiple forms, I love telling a good story and hope to tell impactful ones about the fandom's side of the Entertainment industry. I found the movie of my life in Christopher Nolan's 2014' s Interstellar, which fascinated me with the perfect blend of science and cinema, leaving me curious about Hollywood. In my leisure time, you will find me indulging in photography, gardening, and cycling.