Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home was a surprising blend of time travel, comedy, and environmentalism which made it one of the biggest hits in 1986. It was the most successful film in the franchise before 2009 and had an everlasting impression on fans. What makes it so lovable is the cast’s dedication and willingness to pitch their ideas for uplifting Star Trek.
The 1986 film would have headed on a little different route if it weren’t for an intervention made by Leonard Nimoy. Any Star Trek fan would be curious to know about these little details that would’ve changed the fate of the franchise, and that is precisely why everyone loves these tidbits, to theorize, and come up with their interpretations of what could’ve been.
Leonard Nimoy Suggested Snails Over Whales
The book The Fifty-Year Mission: The Complete, Uncensored, Unauthorized Oral History of Star Trek: The First 25 Years by Mark A. Altman and Edward Gross is a delight for fans as it offers a comprehensive history of the franchise, with behind-the-scene anecdotes, interviews, and insights.
The book talks about how Star Trek IV was originally set to save a tiny species of fish called the snail darter. These fish were discovered in the late 1970s, and due to their endangered status, had become a symbol of environmental conservation.
According to Harve Bennet, the thought of saving these little insignificant creatures was poetic. However, Leonard Nimoy, the actor who played Spock in the movie and also directed the entire film opposed the idea. Executive producer Ralph Winder spoke about Nimoy’s intentions and how he laid out his ideas.
It was Leonard’s idea about saving the whales as opposed to, as he famously said, ‘trying to save the snail darter.’ Saving Whales made it a bigger movie.
Nimoy was influenced by his conversations with environmental scientists and futurists and wanted the film to reflect the same. He wanted to create an entertaining yet thought-provoking movie that highlighted our growing ecological concerns.
In book Biophilia, he tells us we could be losing as many as ten thousand species off this planet per year—many of them having gone unrecorded.
Edward O. Wilson’s book Biophilia served as an inspiration for his ideas in the novel Star Trek project. The author introduced the idea of a keystone species whose loss could come as great damage and cause a domino effect in our ecosystem.
The Impact of Leonard Nimoy’s Creative Choice
Leonard Nimoy’s decision to focus on humpback whales rather than snail darters turned out to be a game changer for the film, and the majestic creatures became central characters that made the narrative compelling, both visually and thematically.
The director wanted to lighten up the darker aspects of the movie with lighter tones by adding a humorous adventure. The inclusion of humpback whales led to a dramatic and engaging plotline, that wouldn’t have been possible with small fish as it would limit the film’s scope and appeal.
This huge creative shift transformed a modest idea into something memorable and impactful that resonated with people all around the world. Moreover, they were able to deliver a poignant environmental message with their standout entry in the Star Trek franchise.
You can stream Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home on Paramount+.
