“It’s a little complicated”: Makoto Yukimura was Forced to Change his Initial Idea for Vinland Saga After His Editor Absolutely Hated the Original Concept

Makoto Yukimura's initial origin of Vinland Saga was rejected by his editor because it was missing the most common Viking trait.

“It’s a little complicated”: Makoto Yukimura was Forced to Change his Initial Idea for Vinland Saga After His Editor Absolutely Hated the Original Concept

SUMMARY

  • Makoto Yukimura, the creator of Vinland Saga, began his manga by making Thorfinn a slave, but this idea was rejected by his editor and he had to changed.
  • Later, he began Vinland Saga by starting with Thorfinn's past as as Viking before making him a slave, and this impressed his editor-in-chief and they began with the serialization.
  • Makoto Yukimura's editor said that since this was a Viking story, starting it off with a slave story will not make it popular, instead a fight or a war in the beginning will make it a worthy Viking plot.
Show More
Featured Video

Vinland Saga season 2 was one of the most anticipated anime of 2023. Season 1 finished airing in 2019, and the fans were eagerly waiting for the sequel. After four years of waiting, the anime came back with a second season, and as usual, it delivered one of the best shows of the year. Makoto Yukimura beautifully designed the characters and caught every minute detail to make it a masterpiece.

Advertisement

Even though the fans have loved the anime and the manga throughout, they will be shocked to hear that initially, the mangaka had different plans for the story. Yumikura had a different beginning to Thorfinn’s journey, but thanks to his editor, it was rejected, and he changed the beginning, and we got ourselves Valhalla.

Vinland Saga Had a Different Beginning

thorfinn
Thorfinn

The story of Thorfinn began with him fighting the Englishmen of England, and through the story’s development, he found himself working as a slave on a farm. But initially, there was no mention of any war or fighting, and the story directly began with Thorfinn being a slave. This idea was completely rejected by his editor, who pointed out that Vinland Saga was a story about Vikings and Vikings who love to fight. Beginning a story as a slave would immediately rejected by the fans.

Advertisement

Also Read: “The first thing I came up with was actually the ending”: Makoto Yukimura Confirms Vinland Saga is Ending Soon as Manga Goes on Hiatus

Makoto Yukimura later mentioned his conversation with his editor in an interview with Anime Trending. He said,

“It’s a little complicated. When I first approached my editor to write the story of Vinland Saga, the story didn’t start where [Thorfinn] was fighting the English in England. Instead, I was planning on a story that started with him being a slave. So, the editor I spoke to at Kodansha said, “Well, that’s not going to sell! A story that starts from being a slave? I thought this story was about the Vikings and fighting, and you’re not going to go into that? How am I going to explain this to my editor-in-chief?” That was the first reaction that I received from my editor.”

makoto yukimura
Makoto Yukimura

The extra fight with the Englishmen helped to put extra weightage on Thorfinn’s character, which was a boon for Vinland Saga, as well as for the fans who enjoyed it throughout.

Advertisement

Also Read: “You should consider Attack on Titan”: Vinland Saga Creator Shuts Down Fans for Demanding More Violence in His Epic Viking Tale

More on Vinland Saga

Vinland Saga has a total of 48 episodes, which is divided into two seasons equally. The manga has over 200 chapters and more than 5000 pages in total. MAPPA Studios was responsible for the amazing animation of the anime, and they looked after every minute detail from the manga. Vinland Saga is yet to announce the release date of the third season.

Vinland Saga
Vinland Saga

Makoto Yukimura is quite thankful to his editor since he hated the original concept of Vinland Saga. Due to the insights, Yukimura improved his manga and made a masterpiece. After the duo worked on it, they presented it to the editor-in-chief, who was quite impressed with the work and began serialization immediately. Yukimura might be the only person in the world who has benefited from his editor’s hatred.

Advertisement

Vinland Saga manga is available on Viz Media, and the anime can be streamed on Crunchyroll, Netflix, and Amazon Prime Video.

Also Read: Vinland Saga Copied Attack on Titan Sequence – The Real Truth Explained

Priyanko Chakraborty

Written by Priyanko Chakraborty

Articles Published: 645

Priyanko is a Content Writer at FandomWire, and specializes in anime. He is currently pursuing his Master's Degree in Economics. Priyanko has previously worked as a content writing intern. He spends half of his day writing on anime, and the other half watching it.