Lawmen Bass Reeves Season 1 Review: Oyelowo Shines

Paramount+ series Lawmen Bass Reeves Season 1 Review and Plot Summary; David Oyelowo gives a remarkable performance in the Paramount+ series Lawmen Bass Reeves


  • This is a review and plot summary of Lawmen Bass Reeves.
  • David Oyelowo gives a remarkable performance in the new series.
  • Lawmen Bass Reeves is worth watching because of David Oyelowo.
Show More
Featured Video

We review the new Paramount+ series Lawmen Bass Reeves and the article does not contain spoilers.


With Lawmen Bass Reeves, Taylor Sheridan has gone from being one of the most daring voices in film to the ultimate provider of “dad” television across your streaming waves. However, that’s not necessarily a bad thing. The man responsible for Paramount+ franchises such as Yellowstone franchises, The Mayor of Kingstown, Special Ops: Lioness, and Tulsa King has carved a very profitable niche in the past decade.


Lawmen Bass Reeves, like 1883 and 1923, is a homage to the golden age of classic Westerns. Led by a remarkable performance from its star David Oyelowo and Sheridan’s socially conscious writing, this will surely be another hit for Paramount+. Lawmen Bass Reeves is a marriage of modern dad television that people crave.

Paramount+ series Lawmen Bass Reeves Season 1 Review and Plot Summary

Lawmen Bass Reeves
The new Paramount+ series Lawmen Bass Reeves premiers November 5th, 2023.

Bass Reeves (Oyelowo) was a legendary lawman but a former enslaved black man who lived most of his life in the state of Arkansas. However, before that, he followed his master, Colonel George Reeves (Shea Whigham), into battle, fighting for the Confederacy. (Yes, this is where Bass’s last name came from.) Bass earns the respect of his master and Esau Pierce (Barry Pepper). Even though he’s fighting for the South, Reeves tells his fellow black man that he’d rather get shot in the face than in the back.


After surviving the battle, in a powerful scene, Bass goes on the run after beating his master for cheating him in a card game with his freedom at stake. Leaving the Reeves home was not an easy decision for Bass. That’s because he left his love, Lauren (City on a Hill’s Jennie Reeves), behind for the simple reason he would have been hanged if he had stayed behind. Bass travelers to Florida, known as an indigenous territory, but his past catches up with him.

From there, Reeves tries to find peace in farming, but he needs the money for his family. He is seen as useful because of his knowledge of various indigenous languages. Bass is brought along on a trip with the Marshal Service. Collaborating with Sherill Lynn (Dennis Quaid) makes Reeves question if the men holding a badge or any better than the criminals they are chasing. However, Bass performs so well at the job that a local judge (Donald Sutherland) swears Reeves in as a U.S. Marshal.


Also Read: “He’s a tough thing to resist”: Carrie Fisher Defended Meg Ryan’s Affair With Russell Crowe That Broke Her 9 Years of Marriage With Dennis Quaid

David Oyelowo gives a remarkable performance in the Paramount+ series Lawmen Bass Reeves.

Lawmen Bass Reeves
David Oyelowo and Lauren E. Banks star in the Paramount+ series Lawmen Bass Reeves.

Lawmen Bass Reeves is based on the Sidney Thompson books Follow the Angels, Follow the Doves: The Bass Reeves Trilogy, Book One, and Hell on the Border: The Bass Reeves Trilogy, Book Two. This is an inherently thought-provoking story. That’s because most Westerns made in the “Golden Age” of the genre, and even today, refuse to tell the story of one of the first black men in law enforcement at the time.


The first four episodes were made available for critics. Executive produced by Sheridan, written and directed by Chad Feehan (Ray Donovan), the series is entertaining and at its best when David Oyelowo explores the atrocities of how non-white citizens are treated in post-Civil War America.

The slow tears that slowly trickle down Oyelowos’ cheeks are deeply felt at the prospect of being free. So is the empathy he has for others. For example, in a raw scene of a young black teenager, practically a child, who pushed over a white man when stealing some food because he was starving.


While seeing the treatment through the Bass Reeve’s eyes, the series so far hardly explores how much racism and bigotry Reeves suffered after being sworn in as a lawman. Surely, he would have received his share of bigotry from the men he arrested. Not to mention the ones he would now rub shoulders with.

Also Read: Silo Review: An Engaging Dystopian Mystery Thriller


Is the Paramount+ series Lawmen Bass Reeves worth watching?

Lawmen Bass Reeves
Dennis Quaid stars in the Paramount+ series Lawmen Bass Reeves.

The sole reason to watch Lawmen Bass Reeves is for the powerful and poignant David Oyelowo performance. The acclaimed British actor, so good in Selma and the little-seen Don’t Let Go, is simply brilliant in the role here. Tender, tough, and remarkably human, Oyelowo transcends the Western trope that comes with the genre by being a fully three-dimensional character.

Along with a stellar cast of guest stars like Sutherland, Quaid, Pepper, Whigham, and Garrett Hedlund, Lawmen Bass Reeves is another fine addition to the Paramount+ “dad” television roster.


Grade: 7/10

Also Read: Amid Epic Controversy, Kevin Costner’s Yellowstone Contract Reportedly Includes a “Moral Death” Clause That Show’s Creator Wanted to Violate


The Paramount+ series Lawmen Bass Reeves premieres on November 5th, 2023.


Written by M.N. Miller

M.N. Miller is a film and television critic and a proud member of the Las Vegas Film Critic Society, Critics Choice Association, and a 🍅 Rotten Tomatoes/Tomato meter approved. He holds a Bachelor's Degree from Mansfield University and a Master's from Chamberlain University. However, he still puts on his pants one leg at a time, and that's when he usually stumbles over. When not writing about film or television, he patiently waits for the next Pearl Jam album and chooses to pass the time by scratching his wife's back on Sunday afternoons while she watches endless reruns of California Dreams. M.N. Miller was proclaimed the smartest reviewer alive by actor Jason Isaacs but chose to ignore his obvious sarcasm. You can also find his work on Hidden Remote, InSession Film, Ready Steady Cut, Geek Vibes Nation, and Nerd Alert.