One Piece Theory is Eiichiro Oda’s Darkest, Dirtiest Secret: Shanks Wanted Ace to Eat the Gum Gum Fruit, Not Luffy

Theory suggests Shanks is fulfilling his late captain's wish.

Shanks, Luffy and Ace One Piece

SUMMARY

  • One Piece fan theory claims that initially, the Gomu Gomu no Mi was not aimed for Monkey D. Luffy.
  • Shanks wanted to fulfil his former captain's wish and wanted to his son to become the next JoyBoy.
  • Eiichiro Oda's plot twist or twist of fate might have changed Hito Hito no Mi, Model: Nika's trajectory.
Show More
Featured Video

In every corner of One Piece, there lies a mystery. Eiichiro Oda created his magnum opus in such a way that the fans get lost in the mysteries. He also reveals them when the time is right. But there are still a few mysteries that often make the fans question the entire plot. One of those questions is whether Red Haired Shanks stole the Gomu Gomu no Mi for Monkey D. Luffy or if there was another pirate destined to become Sun God Nika.

Advertisement

While it seems a mind-boggling question, several theories believe that Gol D. Roger’s son, Portgas D. Ace, was supposed to eat the Gomu Gomu no Mi. But thanks to Eiichiro Oda, Monkey D. Luffy came out of nowhere to consume the fruit. Unknowingly, it was JoyBoy’s Devil Fruit, Hito Hito no Mi, Model: Nika.

Monkey D. Luffy Came Out Of Syllabus For Shanks

Monkey D. Luffy in One Piece
Monkey D. Luffy in One Piece (Credits: Toei Animation)

According to the latest One Piece fan theory, Shanks was supposed to deliver the Gomu Gomu no Mi to Portgas D. Ace. After Gol D. Roger reached Laugh Tale, he came to know that he came several years before JoyBoy’s reincarnation.  He said that he still had time to make a son. Even though Shanks was not present at Laugh Tale, he came to know about his Captain’s wish.

Advertisement

Shanks was going to give the Gum Gum Fruit to Ace
byu/lusalu2 inOnePiece

He took it upon himself to help his son become the next Pirate King. Years later, he came to know about the Hito Hito no Mi, Model: Nika, which went by Gomu Gomu no Mi. He stole it to feed it to Ace. It explains why he was on Dawn Island. Even though he did not know Ace personally, he might have found out that he was on that island. But Monkey D. Luffy came out of the syllabus.

Fans believe Shanks is on the same level as Gol D. Roger
Red Haired Shanks (Credits: Toei Animation)

Red-Haired Shanks did not even know Luffy. It could be that Luffy saying the exact same words as Roger made him change his mind, or it might have been a mistake. Moreover, only the Devil Fruit would know who would be the best candidate to inherit JoyBoy’s abilities. When Roger visited the Ryugu Kingdom, he and Kozuki Oden heard the Sea Kings discussing the birth of two Sovereigns in the future.

Advertisement

One was the reincarnation of Poseidon, Shirahoshi, and another one was JoyBoy. They also said that they would meet in the future. Luffy met Shirahoshi, but the latter has yet to meet Sun God Nika. For this reason, Roger might have ordered his crewmembers to aid JoyBoy in his endeavors. Shanks, Crocus, Rayleigh, etc., all helped Luffy on his journey. 

Shanks Waited For JoyBoy’s Return Before Targeting The One Piece

Shanks Declares to Claim One Piece | Viz Media
Shanks Declares to Claim One Piece (Credits: Viz Media)

Red Haired Shanks’ main motive was to identify JoyBoy. It may be Roger who ordered him to find him and give him the desired Devil Fruit. While the Roger Pirates waited multiple years to reach Loderstar Island, Luffy is heading to Laugh Tale within two years after becoming a pirate. He was helped by Crocus, trained by Rayleigh to unlock his full potential, and aided by Kozuki Oden’s retainers.

Everything that Roger wished for was being carried out by his crewmates. It sounds strange, but there is a reason why Shanks waited so long to claim the One Piece. The theory suggests that he was waiting for JoyBoy’s reincarnation to get hold of his full potential. Before announcing his will to find the One Piece, Shanks was looking at Luffy’s new poster. He is trying to keep his promise to his former captain.

Advertisement
luffy eating hito hito no mi
Luffy eating Hito Hito no Mi, Model: Nika (Credits: Toei Animation)

Eiichiro Oda’s plot twist helped Luffy become Sun God Nika. While it was aimed for Ace, he suffered a tragic death. It became a significant moment in Luffy’s life. Shanks did everything for Luffy that he was supposed to do for Ace. But everything is a fan theory for now. Whether it is a dark plot twist or the work of fate is unknown.

One Piece can be streamed on Crunchyroll.

Priyanko Chakraborty

Written by Priyanko Chakraborty

Articles Published: 700

Priyanko is a Content Writer at FandomWire, and specializes in anime. He is currently pursuing his Master's Degree in Economics. Priyanko has previously worked as a content writing intern. He spends half of his day writing on anime, and the other half watching it.