“Slow and boring? No thanks”: Rockstar Fans Are Concerned That GTA 6 Will Be Too Similar To Red Dead Redemption 2

Will GTA 6 balance its tone between realism and satire, or will it lean too heavily towards Red Dead Redemption 2's serious approach?

gta 6, red dead redemption 2

SUMMARY

  • Some fans fear GTA 6 might be too similar to Red Dead Redemption 2, losing its unique identity.
  • The Grand Theft Auto series is known for its chaotic gameplay and fast-paced action, which might be compromised if it adopts a slower pace.
  • Rockstar faces a challenge in balancing storytelling and immersion with the need to retain GTA's signature elements.
Show More
Featured Video

In the world of Grand Theft Auto, fans have grown accustomed to a certain level of chaos and freedom that defines the series. And with the upcoming release of GTA 6, anticipation is high, but so are the expectations.

Advertisement

The beloved series has always been about fast-paced action, humor, and the ability to wreak havoc in an open-world setting. However, with the success of Red Dead Redemption 2, some fans are worried that GTA 6 might adopt a similar, more serious tone.

The Fear of Homogenization

×

When PC Gamer’s Andy Kelly expressed his desire for Grand Theft Auto 6 to be “more like Red Dead Redemption 2,” one fan’s response instantly forced some frowns:

Advertisement

Red Dead Redemption 2 is widely acclaimed for its storytelling, character development, and immersive open-world experience. However, its slower pace and more serious tone might not be what every GTA fan is looking for.

The Grand Theft Auto series has traditionally been about freedom, chaos, and the tools you have at your disposal to cause all-out mayhem in an open-world setting, which is a far cry from the more methodical and story-driven experience of the Red Dead Redemption series.

The concern is that if GTA 6 adopts a similar approach, it might lose the essence of what makes the series so beloved. Fans love the fast-paced action, the absurd missions, and the freedom to explore and cause chaos in a vibrant, satirical world.

Advertisement

Fan Expectations and the Future of GTA

A scene from the GTA 6 trailer featuring Lucia in the front seat of a car, holding a stack of cash.
It’ll be interesting to see how GTA 6 finds that middle ground. | Image Credit: Rockstar Games

The debate over what the game “should be like” is a reflection of the differing expectations within the gaming community. Some fans are eager for a more serious, story-driven experience, while others prefer the classic formula of action, humor, and chaos:

Ultimately, Rockstar Games must find a way to balance these expectations and deliver a game that is both true to its roots and innovative enough to stand out. By doing so, they can ensure that it is not just another iteration but a game that sets new standards for the open-world genre.

The company’s history of pushing boundaries with each new title suggests that GTA 6 will easily surpass Red Dead Redemption 2 in terms of graphics and technical capabilities. The new RAGE engine promises significant improvements over its predecessor, potentially making the game look and feel more realistic than ever before.

Advertisement

However, the concern remains that the game’s tone might not align with what fans of the series have come to expect.

GTA has always been centered around surrealism, juxtaposing realistic elements with bombastic, over-the-top satire and larger-than-life characters. This is a stark contrast to the realism and serious storytelling of Red Dead.

What do you think about the direction the upcoming game should take? Should it follow in the footsteps of the developer’s current magnum opus or stick to its traditional formula? Let us know in the comments below!

Advertisement
Avatar

Written by Soumyajit Mukherjee

Articles Published: 140

Soumyajit (ign: LockDown) is a die-hard PC gamer with a passion for competitive FPS games, having played Rainbow Six Siege at a competitive level in the past. For nearly two years, he has turned his love for gaming and writing into a profession, delivering the latest gaming news and guides to his readers. And when he is not writing or dominating the lobby in Call of Duty or Valorant, you can find him in theaters watching the latest comic book films or binge-watching anime and thriller flicks!