“The tyranny of Messmer’s flame”: Shadow of the Erdtree Trailer Reveals a War Deadlier Than The Shattering – Why Did Hidetaka Miyazaki Hide it From Us?

Hidetaka Miyaza should've revealed Messmur's attack on The Lands Between before the upcoming Elden Ring DLC.

shadow of the erdtree trailer, the shattering

SUMMARY

  • The latest Shadow of the Erdtree DLC trailer gives players more insight into what to expect.
  • Elden Ring's game director, Hidetaka Miyazaki, is known for creating rich narratives that task players with exploring the game world.
  • However, many players wonder why Hidetaka Miyazaki didn't reveal this crucial Elden Ring lore before the upcoming DLC release.
Show More
Featured Video

In the last couple of weeks, we’ve seen the Elden Ring developer FromSoftware dropping a few teases here and there about its upcoming Shadow of the Erdtree DLC. However, the studio has given us our best look yet at the DLC since it was first revealed. 

Advertisement

Elden Ring’s upcoming DLC has been a long time coming and anticipated due to FromSoftware’s proven track record with DLCs in its other games, such as Dark Souls. However, one of the most striking aspects of the latest trailer was the revelation of a war much deadlier than The Shattering. This has led to many players in the community questioning why the game’s director, Hidetaka Miyazaki, hid such a crucial piece of the lore, which changes everything we know about the upcoming Elden Ring DLC.

Why Did Hidetaka Miyazaki Hide Messmer’s Attack on The Lands Between?

Hidetaka Miyazaki surprises players with another crucial Elden Ring lore detail | Steam

Elden Ring‘s Shadow of the Erdtree DLC is just around the corner, and FromSoftware has just given us a brand-new story trailer to prepare us for our adventure into the Land of the Shadow.

Advertisement
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6uT8wGtB3yQ

The stunning trailer showcases the upcoming DLC’s main antagonist, Messmer the Impaler, in his fiery glory as he sacks the Land of Shadow. That’s not all; we also get glimpses of some new horrifying features, a shot of Tarnished in unique armor sets, and snippets featuring what looks to be both Miqella and Marika in certain historical moments. 

One of the most unexpected revelations in the trailer was that Messmer also waged war on The Lands Between. While it’s likely that this happened before The Shattering, it’s surprising that we have absolutely no mention of this war in the base game. 

If Miyazaki had been planning something this huge for a DLC that changes the lore of the first game, he should’ve revealed it ages ago. The studio had no reason to wait until the DLC’s reveal to give us such banger news that there was a war even deadlier than The Shattering in Elden Ring’s universe.

Advertisement

Messmer’s wrath on The Lands Between needs a proper explanation because his attack would’ve also dragged the Demigods. If he’s still alive, that means even Demigods couldn’t take him down, proving his incredible strength. It took Marika banishing him and his army to end his activities.

FromSoft Itself Needs Help Understanding Hidetaka Miyazaki’s Mind

FromSoftware developers need help understanding Hidetaka Miyazaki’s decisions | Steam

It’s not the first time we’ve seen Hidetaka Miyazaki hiding crucial pieces of lore in his games. He has quite a history of doing so and wants to avoid spoon-feeding everything to the players. The game director believes that players can gather all the inputs and put the story together. However, it’s not only gamers who need help understanding Miyazaki’s mind; even FromSoftware developers don’t have a shred of an idea of what’s going on in his mind!

Miyazaki and Masaaki Yamagi, one of the former producers at FromSoftware, talked about Bloodborne in the Drained Blood interview with Future Press. At one point, the interviewer brought up how Vicar Amelia’s post-fight cutscene in the game can leave a lot for players to imagine. Although Miyazki agreed that gamers can imagine a lot from what’s going on in the scene, Yamagiwa revealed that he had absolutely no idea what was happening. 

Advertisement

Miyazaki wasn’t surprised and said most of the studio would’ve agreed with Yamagiwa then. Only after viewing a video that explained the game’s story easily did one of the developers say they could finally understand what was happening in the story. 

Avatar

Written by Dhruv Bhatnagar

Articles Published: 131

Dhruv has been an avid gamer all his life, with an emphasis on multiplayer titles. After switching to PC, he has dabbled in the world of GTA Online ever since its release. He aims to spread his passion for gaming through his writing.