“This girl’s big sin? That she ate some pizza?”: George Clooney Movie Invited Controversy for Fat-Shaming $238M Movie Co-Star Alicia Silverstone

"This girl's big sin? That she ate some pizza?": George Clooney Movie Invited Controversy for Fat-Shaming $238M Movie Co-Star Alicia Silverstone
Featured Video

Joel Schumacher’s Batman & Robin, to this very date, remains a widely chastised cinematic disaster. Frowned upon by critics and mocked by the audience, the 1997 film was flogged for being the worst Batman film ever made. 
Batman & Robin
Batman & Robin (1997)

From its campy elements and a clash of styles to poor casting paired with cheesy and inconsistent dialogues, there were so many oddities in the movie that people couldn’t stop nitpicking even if they wanted to. And as if all that wasn’t calamitous enough already, the George Clooney-led superhero flick paved the way for even more censure thanks to the controversies it ignited. Case in point, the infamous n**ple Batsuit and fat shaming of a cast member.


Batman & Robin – The Ultimate Recipe for Disaster 

Not only did the WB flop become the subject of critical admonishment, but it also ended up being a box office bomb, grossing only $238.2 million globally against a hefty budget of $125-160 million. The Hollywood Reporter even deemed it an exorbitant “toy commercial” in the name of a movie. But besides the flashy and abject direction along with unimpressive dialogues and overall poor execution that contributed to the film’s wretchedness, several other controversial aspects were also to be blamed for its failure. Body shaming Batgirl was never going to bode well anyways.

Alicia Silverstone, who portrayed the female counterpart of George Clooney‘s Bruce Wayne, was put through a horrible time for gaining weight on set. Multiple scenes with Batgirl didn’t make it to the film because the wardrobe team was required to refit Silverstone’s costume while Batman & Robin was still in production.

Alicia Silverstone
Alicia Silverstone

“What is this girl’s big sin – that she ate some pizza?”, the director defended her after media outlets criticized the actress for being “too fat.” Schumacher standing up for her publicly was probably the only good thing about the entirety of the project. 

See also: “I can’t say that it was that much fun”: George Clooney Protected and Took Care of Alicia Silverstone While Shooting the Biggest Flop of His Career ‘Batman and Robin’

Joel Schumacher’s Batman Film Made Alicia Silverstone Miserable 

Sure, the filmmaker publicly defended the Clueless star and stood by her side through it all, but that didn’t mean she’d simply forget all the vile names the paparazzi called her or the disgusting things tabloids wrote about her. “Fatgirl” was certainly not what a 20-year-old actress would want to gain popularity for.


“That definitely wasn’t my [favorite] filmmaking experience,” Silverstone said of Batman & Robin in an interview with The Guardian. “There were working circumstances that were less than [favorable] in terms of how things went down.”

Alicia Silverstone as Batgirl

While she worked with industry A-listers like Clooney as well as Uma Thurman and Arnold Schwarzenegger, the Batman venture still held a trunk of bitter memories for her, and understandably so. For Silverstone, the movie was one big, horrible experience that made her “stop loving acting for a very long time,” probably rendering her as miserable as it did fans.

Batman & Robin can be streamed on HBO Max.


See also: Despite all the Fan Hate ‘Batman and Robin’ Was One of the Highest Earning Movies of George Clooney With $238.2 Million Worldwide Collection

Source: The Guardian

Why Michael Keaton Is The Best Batman | FandomWire Video Essay


Written by Khushi Shah

Articles Published: 819

With a prolific knowledge of everything pop culture and a strong penchant for writing, Khushi has penned over 700 articles during her time as an author at FandomWire.
An abnormal psychology student and an fervent reader of dark fiction, her most trusted soldiers are coffee and a good book.