“We will see Peter Parker”: Tobey Maguire or Andrew Garfield’s Return as Spider-Man in Dakota Johnson’s Madam Web Doesn’t Look Impossible

Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield's potential return in Madame Web.

"We will see Peter Parker": Tobey Maguire or Andrew Garfield's Return as Spider-Man in Dakota Johnson's Madam Web Doesn't Look Impossible


  • Dakota Johnson's upcoming superhero film Madame Web is set to extend Sony's Spider-Verse.
  • Speculations surrounding Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield's potential return in the upcoming film have been circulating for a while.
  • Cassandra Webb's ability to foresee the future could also potentially entangle Spider-Man appearances with her visions.
Show More
Featured Video

Dakota Johnson’s upcoming superhero film Madame Web is set to extend Sony’s Spider-Verse further and there has been eager anticipation among fans for the potential return of Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield. Madame Web revolves around Cassandra Webb, a New York paramedic, embarking on a mission to rescue three young girls from a mysterious adversary. The movie is poised to join the ranks of Venom, Morbius, and Kraven the Hunter in Sony’s expanding Spider-Verse.

Madame Webb
Madame Webb

The two Spider-Man stars were last seen alongside Tom Holland in Marvel’s Spider-Man: No Way Home. Although uncertainties shroud their potential appearance in the upcoming film, the prospect of their return doesn’t seem entirely impossible.

Read More: Andrew Garfield and 3 Other Actors Who Set a Record by Being Fired from Marvel Movies


Tobey Maguire And Andrew Garfield’s Potential Return in Madame Web

Speculations surrounding Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield’s potential return in the upcoming film Madame Web have been circulating for a while. Rumors had that the movie is supposedly set in the 2000s and may contain hidden Easter eggs about Tobey Maguire’s Spider-Man movies.

Spider-Man: No way Home
Tobey Maguire, and Andrew Garfield in Spider-Man: No Way Home

Notably, a scene in the trailer showcases an individual donning a red and black suit, believed to be a Spider-Man. Additional speculation points to the possibility of a surprise appearance by The Amazing Spider-Man star as well. Some speculations suggest that they could make brief on-screen appearances akin to the style seen in Across the Spider-Verse.

However, some rumors even suggest that these appearances could be reserved for post-credit scenes of the movie. Amidst the buzz, fans are eagerly anticipating seeing Peter Parker in the movie, especially as the storyline involves characters like Ben Parker and Mary Parker.


As @blurayangel asked about Spider-Man’s potential appearance in the Dakota Johnson starrer, one X (Twitter) user said, “Over 50% we’ll see Peter Parker. Under 50% we’ll see Spider-Man.” Cassandra Webb’s ability to foresee the futures of other superheroes could also potentially entangle Spider-Man appearances with her visions of the future.

Read More: “They’re all imaginary and CG”: Real Reason Tobey Maguire’s Spider-Man 2 is Light Years Better Than Tom Holland’s No Way Home

Madame Web Features Multiple Spider-Man Characters

While there is anticipation to see Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire’s return in the upcoming film, Madame Web is set to introduce a diverse array of Spider-People. The movie follows Cassandra Webb teaming up with Julia Carpenter (Spider-Woman), along with Mattie Franklin, and Anya Corazon (Araña and later Spider-Girl in the comics).

Madame Web
Madame Web

The trailer provides a sneak peek at Julia, Mattie, and Anya donning their superhero costumes and engaging in combat. However, it remains uncertain whether these scenes are part of Cassandra’s visions or if the characters will undergo their complete transformations within the movie.

Read More: “I was scratching my head wondering”: Not Spider-Man, Kate Winslet Called Tobey Maguire’s Weirdest Role in a Tom Cruise Movie His Crowning Achievement

Tahar Rahim portrays Ezekiel Sims, previously seen as a Spider therapist in Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse. Although Madame Web doesn’t seem to rely on Spider-Man at this point, it introduces a captivating lineup of Spider-People and an enigmatic antagonist in Sims.


Madame Web is set to release on February 14, 2024.


Written by Laxmi Rajput

Articles Published: 2227

Laxmi Rajput is a writer at Fandomwire. She finished her Post Graduation in Broadcast Journalism and worked as a Business News writer for a year. But her interest in entertainment and pop culture compelled her to find a way towards Entertainment Journalism. She has worked across various fields and has 2 years of experience in content writing. She likes reading, music, movies, and traveling. She aspires to become a fiction writer in the future.