“Who wants to watch a movie with heroes fighting heroes?”: Robert Downey Jr, Chris Evans’ Iron Man vs Captain America Battle Was Almost Entirely Different

The chairman of The Walt Disney Studios, Alan Horn, sided with the Russos' vision and allowed Captain America 3 to go ahead.

"Who wants to watch a movie with heroes fighting heroes?": Robert Downey Jr, Chris Evans' Iron Man vs Captain America Battle Was Almost Entirely Different

SUMMARY

  • The production of Captain America: Civil War was difficult and almost led to the directors getting fired due to creative differences with the studio.
  • The movie's third act involves the heroes fighting against each other, which was not met with approval from higher-ups at the MCU.
  • The Russos wanted it to be more in line with their other big Marvel hits, but the studio wanted to go a safer route.
Show More
Featured Video

Getting their version of Captain America: Civil War made wasn’t an easy task, as the creative heads in the studio butted heads with the Russo Brothers, which almost led to the directors getting fired. While Civil War, starring Robert Downey Jr and Chris Evans, doesn’t have the Avengers title labeled to it, it is no less than any of those movies and is often considered the very best MCU has to offer.

Advertisement

Unlike most MCU third-acts, where the heroes fight against some CGI monstrosity and his faceless goons, Civil War strays away from that, as the Russos didn’t want it to be a typical superhero outing. However, their decision to do that wasn’t met with laudation from the studio higher-ups, as they wanted it to be more in line with their other big Marvel hits.

Also read: MCU’s Godfather Robert Downey Jr Surprisingly Was Not the Highest Paid Actor in Iron Man

Advertisement
Robert Downey Jr and Chris Evans | Captain America: Civil War
Robert Downey Jr and Chris Evans | Captain America: Civil War

Robert Downey Jr and Chris Evan’s Fight Almost Didn’t Happen

Captain America: Civil War‘s third act, which sees Robert Downey Jr‘s Iron Man fighting against Chris Evan’s Captain America, is arguably one of the most powerful sequences in the MCU. However, the creative heads at the MCU weren’t too pleased with the idea of heroes fighting each other, as they wanted to go a safer route. That would’ve involved the Avengers taking on some super soldiers and ultimately saving the day, which was deemed too predictable by the Russo brothers, who held on to their guns. Per MCU: The Reign of Marvel Studios,

“The Committee proposed a different version in which the heroes team up to fight a bunch of unfrozen Super Soldiers. As Kyle remembered it, ‘We were discussing Civil War and the question posed to us is, ‘Who wants to watch a movie with heroes fighting heroes?'” 

Fortunately, Kevin Feige stood beside the directors, and eventually, Alan Horn, the chairman of The Walt Disney Studios, took matters into his own hands and sided with the Russos’ vision.

Also read: “I legally probably can’t even accept it”: Marvel Producer Got Into an Ugly Spot With Iron Man 3 Writer Before He Was Hired For Robert Downey Jr.’s Movie

Advertisement
Civil War marvel comics
Captain America: Civil War

The Russo Brothers Want Fans to Be Patient About MCU’s New Direction

While things have gone off the rails for the MCU since the Russos parted ways with MCU, they are optimistic about Marvel’s future, urging fans to be patient as the MCU is dealing with a very different story. Joe Russo said,

“They’re telling you a very different story, a very new story and I think the audience just needs to be patient with the redirection because you can’t keep telling the same story over and over or you lose the audience.”

Also read: Avengers are in Danger: Robert Downey Jr Returns as Evil Multiverse Variant To Show Kang Who’s Boss in Secret Wars Fan Art

Marvel
Marvel Studios

Although turning our favorite heroes against each other was a bold move, fans are grateful Marvel went that route instead of sticking to the Avengers taking on some one-dimensional villains.

Advertisement

Captain America: Civil War is available to stream on Disney Plus.

Avatar

Written by Santanu Roy

Articles Published: 1439

Santanu Roy is a film enthusiast with a deep love for the medium of animation while also being obsessed with The Everly Brothers, Billy Joel, and The Platters. Having expertise in everything related to Batman, Santanu spends most of his time watching and learning films, with Martin Scorsese and Park Chan-wook being his personal favorites. Apart from pursuing a degree in animation, he also possesses a deep fondness for narrative-driven games and is currently a writer at Fandomwire with over 1000 articles.