“The movie would be a little bit longer”: Zack Snyder Didn’t Include the Most Crucial Watchmen Scene to Include His Favorite Sequence in the Movie

Zack Snyder defended his decision not to feature the Squid Monster for years!

“The movie would be a little bit longer”: Zack Snyder Didn’t Include the Most Crucial Watchmen Scene to Include His Favorite Sequence in the Movie


  • Zack Snyder directed the 2009 film titled Watchmen that was supposed to feature the Squid Attack.
  • Citing runtime constraints as the reason, Snyder revealed that he opted to make Doctor Manhattan the main antagonist rather than the Squid Monster.
  • In a recent interview, however, the director revealed that he would have included the Squid Monster if the movie were made today!
Show More
Featured Video

Zack Snyder has been known to faithfully adapt comic books and graphic novels into full-fledged films until the last minute. With some minor changes that essentially change the entire story, Snyder has often found himself on the opposite side of precise adaptations.


Talking about the 2009 film titled Watchmen, Zack Snyder chose to omit a pretty big event from the graphic novel. Stating that there was no need for the Squid Attack, Snyder defended his decision for years before finally admitting that it wouldn’t have been such a bad idea to include the plot after all!

Zack Snyder on the sets of Watchmen
Zack Snyder on the sets of Watchmen

Why Zack Snyder Chose To Replace The Squid Attack!

Zack Snyder faithfully adapted the graphic novel into Watchmen. However, he changed the finale a bit. With Doctor Manhattan as the main villain instead of the Squid Monster, Snyder felt that Dr. Manhattan as the villain would make more sense.

A still of Alien Monster from the TV series Watchmen (2019)
A still of Alien Monster from the TV series Watchmen (2019)

Also read: “I don’t audition for a ton of things”: Ray Fisher on His Future in Hollywood After His Big Return in Zack Snyder’s Rebel Moon Following DCU Exit

The director defended his decision to omit the Squid Attack for years with different reasons. In a recent interview, the veteran director revealed to Uproxx that he might have considered including the Squid Attack if Watchmen was made today!

“By the way, I love ‘Watchmen.’ I have no regrets. I love that movie 100 percent/ It’s exactly what I wanted. And in some ways, I think there’s a great college class that someone could teach on the difference between Doctor Manhattan and the squid. And why we would have chosen Doctor Manhattan and how thematically that works as it relates to the climax of that book.”

He further continued,


“But I would also say, that based on doing the movie that I just did, ‘Justice League,’ I might consider it. Only because I feel like it would have required a slightly longer movie to do the squid, than say, Doctor Manhattan.”

As the interview further progressed, the veteran director revealed that if they had included the Squid Attack, they would have to remove one of Snyder’s favorite sequences from the film!

Suggested: “Religion’s a dangerous ground. That’s a minefield”: Henry Cavill Against Superman-Jesus Comparison

Zack Snyder Had A Runtime Constraint

Zack Snyder's Watchmen (2009)
Zack Snyder’s Watchmen (2009)

Related: “The humble root that he comes from”: Zack Snyder’s Ideal James Bond Casting Would Upset Henry Cavill Fans Despite His Close Bond With Superman Star


Back in 2009, the director did not have as much creative freedom over his projects as he does now. With a runtime constraint on the director, Snyder revealed that he could have included the squid Attack but for that, the director would have had to remove one of his favorite sequences.

“It was probably best not to [include the squid] because it would’ve ended up adding another 15 pages to the script. You know, just to kind of make that make sense.”

The sequence that Snyder was talking about was the funeral of the Comedian. Choosing his favorite sequences over the Squid Attack storyline, Snyder released Watchmen which was quite a success! The 2009 film received a rating of 7.6/10 on IMDB and an average of 65% on Rotten Tomatoes. The film is currently available to stream on Max in the U.S.


Written by Visarg Acharya

Articles Published: 2267

Visarg Acharya, Associate Content Writer, has been heavily involved in movies, series, and history. Having an experience of 2 years in the field of content writing, Visarg is a seasoned writer. Having a degree in Physics, Visarg Acharya has published a dissertation alongside a plethora of poems and short stories along the way.