“There’s no chance you’re topping the first few seasons”: Michael C. Hall Doesn’t Seem to Learn from His Mistakes as Actor Confirmed to Return as Dexter for the 2nd Time

Fans feel that the Dexter prequel and sequel, both featuring Michael C. Hall, are too much Dexter for them.

michael c. hall as dexter

SUMMARY

  • Michael C. Hall announced another Dexter sequel, titled Resurrection, at the ongoing San Diego Comic-Con.
  • Fans are not happy with the announcement as they didn't want any more sequels after 2021's Dexter: New Blood.
  • Hall's stint as Dexter Morgan began to drop in quality after the first few seasons and the finale season is beyond saving even with sequels.
Show More
Featured Video

It appears that Michael C. Hall isn’t done with the Dexter IP, but fans surely are. During the ongoing San Diego Comic-Con, Hall appeared at the Dexter: Original Sin panel and surprised fans with the announcement of a new sequel series. The newly announced Dexter: Resurrection is reportedly a sequel to New Blood, which was released in 2021 as a sequel to the original show.

Advertisement
jennifer carpenter and michael c. hall dexter
Jennifer Carpenter and Michael C. Hall in Dexter | Showtime

New Blood didn’t do a great job in terms of saving the dumpster fire finale of the original series, but it did a few things right in terms of course correction. Moreover, the show ended with the death of Hall’s main character, which means Resurrection may go out of its way to bring back Dexter Morgan from the dead.

Michael C. Hall Announces Another Dexter Sequel Besides The Upcoming Prequel Show

Dexter series finale
Michael C. Hall and Jennifer Carpenter in the Dexter series finale | Showtime

Michael C. Hall‘s Dexter has gained some traction recently, according to Nielsen charts (via Variety). Showtime is all set to double down on this newfound love for the series, even though it ended on a bad note for many fans.

Advertisement

When the show ended, serial killer Dexter Morgan faced no real-life consequences for his actions. The final scene depicted him to be leading a new life as a lumberjack. Showtime came up with a sequel set 10 years after the OG show ended, titled Dexter: New Blood. The 2021 miniseries tried to fix the original show’s mistake and ended with the main character’s death.

The show was supposed to have a second season with a focus on his son Harrison Morgan. However, it was canceled in favor of an upcoming prequel show Dexter: Original Sin. Interestingly, Hall is set to return to this project in a voice-only role and plays a young Dexter Morgan’s inner voice.

When he appeared at SDCC, fans believed he was there as part of the Original Sin cast. However, a new sequel series announcement from the actor has surely taken fans by surprise. Paramount Global Head Chris McCarthy shared about the new show Dexter: Resurrection (via Variety):

Advertisement

We are thrilled to have the brilliant Michael C. Hall reprise his iconic role as Dexter Morgan in Showtime’s most successful series ever. […] Dexter: Ressurection will appeal to the tens of millions of longtime fans.

The new sequel series will debut in the summer of 2025. Meanwhile, the prequel series starring Patrick Gibson will hit Showtime in December. The prequel series will also feature Christian Slater as Harry Morgan and Molly Brown as Debra Morgan alongside Sarah Michelle Gellar and Patrick Dempsey.

Fans Were Not At All Happy With Another Dexter Sequel With Michael C. Hall

Michael C. Hall and Julia Jones in Dexter: New Blood | Showtime
Michael C. Hall and Julia Jones in Dexter: New Blood | Showtime

While Dexter fans were elated to see Michael C. Hall in the Original Sin panel, they may not have a favorable opinion of another Dexter sequel. Fans on X didn’t, as they clearly stated their disapproval. Fans pointed out that the original show took a nose dive after the first few seasons and never recovered from it.

The recent outing from the franchise, New Blood, was not a major success to have another sequel to pile upon it. The series did a few things right though, but Dexter: Resurrection is likely to undo whatever good the previous series did. Some of the fan reactions read:

Advertisement

Fans can catch Dexter and Dexter: New Blood on Paramount+ with a Showtime subscription. Both Dexter: Original Sin and Dexter: Resurrection will also debut on Paramount+ with Showtime.

Avatar

Written by Hashim Asraff

Articles Published: 1525

Hashim, Entertainment Writer. With over 1000 published articles on FandomWire, he covers a wide range of topics from celebrity life to comic book movies. He holds a Masters degree in Sociology and his expertise proves invaluable in handling sensitive news. His passion for crime investigation thrillers has turned him into a detective, exploring the darkest corners of the internet during his research.