“Why would you make this theory make sense?”: The Wildest Harry Potter Theory is Impossible to Put Down That Explains Why Albus Dumbledore Knew Everything from the Start

Unveiling the theory behind Albus Dumbledore's omniscience in the Wizarding World.

Albus Dumbledore and Harry Potter

SUMMARY

  • For decades, fans have tried to figure out the secret behind Albus Dumbledore's omniscience in the books and the films.
  • Finally, a theory emerged, suggesting that Dumbledore's ability to know everything was attributed to his chocolate frog cards.
  • Citing Dumbledore's deeper connection to his card collection, fans backed their theory by pointing to his fear of losing the cards.
Show More
Featured Video

In the magical world of Harry Potter, Albus Dumbledore is known for his infinite wisdom, foresight, and seemingly boundless knowledge. But what if we tell you, there was a hidden secret behind his omniscience, that connects with his penchant for the Chocolate Frog cards in his honor? 

Advertisement
Michael Gambon as Dumbledore
Michael Gambon as Albus Dumbledore | Warner Bros

A theory has emerged online that proposed a justification for Dumbledore’s ability to know everything. Connecting the dots of his knowledge with his unlikely fondness for his collection of Chocolate Frog cards, netizens shared an intriguing theory suggesting that Dumbledore used the cards to serve his own purposes.

Albus Dumbledore Used the Chocolate Frog Cards as His Secret Network

Apart from being one of the greatest wizards in the magical world of Harry Potter, Albus Dumbledore has undoubtedly baffled everyone with his knowledge about almost everything that’s been going on in the Wizarding World. Whether it was about keeping an eye on Harry’s mischief or being vigilant about the Ministry of Magic, Dumbledore was omniscient. 

Advertisement

But have you ever wondered how he kept himself updated with everything, from time to time? Well, according to a mind-blowing Reddit theory, gunnerdn91 established a connection between Dumbledore’s knowledge and his designated Chocolate Frog cards. Yes, you read it right. According to the user, the magically animated amphibian treats that always came with a single card in honor of famous witches and wizards were being used by Dumbledore as his secret network. 

Comment
byu/SneakerSpek from discussion
inharrypotter

As per the intriguing theory, Albus Dumbledore utilized his extensive collection of Chocolate Frog cards not just for fun, but as a sophisticated network of informants. Similar to how the people in the magical portraits at Hogwarts could move between frames and communicate, the theory suggests that the images on Dumbledore’s chocolate frog cards served as his eyes and ears across the wizarding world.

Dumbledore’s designated Chocolate Frog card | Warner Bros.
Dumbledore’s designated Chocolate Frog card | Warner Bros.

The theory doesn’t sound that surprising, given how Harry had initially lost Dumbledore from his Chocolate Frog card in Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone. This proves that the former headmaster of Hogwarts could go in and out of the cards on his wish. Further, considering how Dumbledore often took advantage of the headmaster’s portrait in his Hogwarts office to send messages and even spy at other locations, his Chocolate Frog counterpart seems justified. 

Advertisement

Dumbledore’s Fear of Losing His Designated Cards in Order of the Phoenix 

However, to back the theory further, a user named FunkyandFresh pointed to a passage in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, where Albus Dumbledore’s words hinted at a deeper connection to his Chocolate Frog cards. From the snippet where the Hogwarts headmaster was stripped of several significant honors, and was removed from the Wizengamot, he surprisingly spoke of the Chocolate Frogs. 

Comment
byu/SneakerSpek from discussion
inharrypotter
Comment
byu/SneakerSpek from discussion
inharrypotter

Claiming that the treatment from the Ministry of Magic didn’t bother him a bit, as long as he wasn’t removed from the Chocolate Frog cards, Albus Dumbledore had perhaps hinted at his secret network. However, considering his quirky ways of lessening the tension, fans and readers had probably considered this statement as one of his humorous bits. 

Michael Gambon as Dumbledore in the Harry Potter franchise
Albus Dumbledore in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix | Warner Bros

Therefore, if we entertain this Harry Potter theory, then it could mean that the headmaster was being actually truthful. But above all, whether the veracity of the theory gets confirmed or not, it surely adds a fascinating layer to Dumbledore’s character. Apart from his vast knowledge, the theory also highlights his strategic insights and ability to stay several steps ahead of others.

Advertisement

Harry Potter films are available on Max. 

Avatar

Written by Krittika Mukherjee

Articles Published: 1747

Krittika is a News Writer at FandomWire with 2 years of prior experience in lifestyle and web content writing. With her previous works available on HubPages and Medium, she has woven over 1700 stories with us, about fan-favorite actors, movies, and shows. Post-graduate in Journalism and Honors-graduate in English Literature, when this art enthusiast isn't crafting your next favorite article, she finds her escapism in coffee, fiction, and the Wizarding World.