“I‘m literally disgusted”: Penn Badgley’s You Season 5 Reusing an Old Trope Could Ruin the Show Forever as First Set Photos Raise Alarm Bells

Joe Goldberg has a potential new obsession in You season 5 and fans aren't happy.

Penn Badgley, You

SUMMARY

  • Penn Badgley will return as Joe Goldberg for the fifth and final season of Netflix's You.
  • Set photos from the new season seem to indicate a new love interest for the infamous serial killer.
  • Fans are tired of the show's trope of introducing new obsessions for Joe every season.
Show More
Featured Video

Penn Badgley’s hit Netflix series You has become a sensation among fans and Joe Goldberg’s chaotic shenanigans impressed fans in the first four seasons. The charismatic yet dangerous serial killer’s thrilling journey kept fans intrigued and the character has done some heinous things throughout his run in the show so far.

Advertisement
Penn Badgley and Victoria Pedretti in You season 3 | Netf;ix
Penn Badgley and Victoria Pedretti in You season 3 | Netflix

One of the recurring narratives of the show is Goldberg’s tendency to kill his old love interest when he falls for a new woman. This aspect has been criticized by some fans as it made the show repetitive. Unfortunately, the final season may be doing the same as the set photos seem to indicate a new love interest for Joe.

You Season 5 Set Photos May Have Confirmed A New Love Interest for Joe Goldberg

After Love and Marienne, Joe plans to settl down with Kate at the end of season 4 of You | Netflix
After Love and Marienne, Joe plans to settle down with Kate at the end of season 4 of You | Netflix

Netflix’s hit series You introduced the world to Penn Badgley’s Joe Goldberg. The infamous serial killer’s complex characterization and Badgley’s compelling performance intrigued fans, even leading for some to have an affinity for him. However, the irredeemable character has followed a particular modus operandi for his victims throughout the four seasons of the show.

Advertisement

Throughout the show. Goldberg always falls for a new woman every season and finds ways to get rid of the one to whom he’s currently committed: Love in season 2, Marienne in season 3, and Kate in season 4. At the end of season 4, Joe thinks of settling down with Kate in New York. However, it seems his old habits are catching up to him once again.

In new set photos of the fifth and final season of You, Badgley’s Joe is seen spending time with a new woman in his life played by Madeline Brewer. Fans are getting tired of getting the same trope every season, and are concerned that the final season will not provide anything new. Here are some of the reactions on X,

Advertisement

Advertisement

While the repetitive trope of the show has certainly become tiring, it falls in line with how Goldberg functions as an individual. His current relationship with Kate is the same thing as what happened with his previous victims and are not born out of true love. As a serial killer, he thrives through obsessing, luring and finally killing his victims. It remains to be seen how Goldberg fares in the final season.

Netflix Exec Teases A Thrilling And Unforgettable Ending For Penn Badgley’s You

You season 5 will most likely see Joe Goldberg's downfall | Netflix
You season 5 will most likely see Joe Goldberg’s downfall | Netflix

Penn Badgley‘s Joe Goldberg and his chaotic adventures are coming to an end with the upcoming final season of You. The final season is currently shooting and its plot is kept under wraps. However, fand will be in for an absolute thrill ride as Netflix’s Vice President of scripted series, Peter Friedlander, teases a terrifying last outing for the infamous serial killer.

Advertisement

Friedlander further stated that Netflix is proud of the growing success and popularity of the show with each season and fans will get an unforgettable ending with the final season. He said (via Netflix Tudum),

We’re proud to see how You has captivated audiences around the world, becoming an instant sensation on Netflix with a resounding cultural impact that has grown season over season. We’re excited — and a bit terrified — to see how it all ends for Joe Goldberg, but one thing is for sure: You are in for an unforgettable ending.

With many loose ends in Joe’s past, they can come to haunt him in the final season and all together work together to take revenge on him. Fans are already speculating that he will face judgment for his actions and may most likely die. All will be known when season 5 comes out in the near future.

Fans can catch up on the first four seasons of You on Netflix. 

Advertisement
Avatar

Written by Rahul Thokchom

Articles Published: 1158

Rahul Thokchom is a senior content writer at Fandomwire who is passionate about covering the world of pop culture and entertainment. He has a Masters Degree in English that contributes to the richness and creativity in his works.