“Change my mind”: Controversial Elden Ring Opinion Draws (a Lot of) Criticism

A redditor walked into trouble when he dissed Elden Ring on the game's subreddit.

"Change my mind": Controversial Elden Ring Opinion Draws (a Lot of) Criticism

SUMMARY

  • Elden Ring is the title that led to the growth and amplification of the Soulslike subgenre and is also responsible for the incredible increase in popularity of FromSoftware.
  • The title was released in 2022, and two years later, it is as relevant as it was.
  • A player's post received a lot of flak; some people took digs, some people expressed disappointment, and some even offered logical arguments.
Show More
Featured Video

Elden Ring took the gaming industry by storm and was a game celebrated by players and reviewers alike. The game took the SoulsBorne formula and applied it to a grand open-world game with one of the most in-depth world-building works, thanks to FromSoftware’s collaboration with George R.R. Martin.

Advertisement

The game also introduced a few mechanics for newcomers to the SoulsBorne genre and FromSoftware games in general. It had mechanics, making it much more accessible than traditional Dark Souls games. Because of this, novices to the subgenre are advised to begin their journey with Elden Ring. On the contrary, some SoulsBorne enthusiasts feel that the game was created for players who couldn’t come to terms with the original Dark Souls games.

One such player posted this opinion on the game’s subreddit and received a lot of flak.

Advertisement

A Bitter Fan Dismisses Elden Ring as a Title for Players Who Handle the Original Dark Souls

An Elden Ring fan posted something on the game's subreddit and sparked a lot of courage.
An Elden Ring fan posted something on the game’s subreddit that sparked a lot of outrage.

A player going by Embarrased_Sky_9218 posted on the game’s official subreddit and had this to say that sparked much outrage from fans. The post currently has zero upvotes, and it makes sense why fans would dislike an opinion putting down players who didn’t play the Souls games.

This is what the post says:

Elden ring is for beta people who can’t get past asylum demon in dark souls 1 change my mind.

The usage of genuinely bitter terms, usually found in an Instagram comment section for a reel appealing to juveniles, was bound to experience a lot of blowback, and it did. Players were visibly unimpressed with the post, and they let it rip in the comment section below.

Advertisement

Some comments highlighted the user’s juvenile behavior and illogical reasoning:

change my mind

Change your diaper first.

Some people also highlighted that this wasn’t news and that the user should have used the correct tag. Also, the poster should attempt to justify why they feel so. Blatantly calling a particular set of gamers “beta” is not indicative of maturity. People also stated that the reason people hate the game is that it is widespread. Popularity always opens up more avenues for criticism than underrated or less popular games.

Some people also stated that this is a joke or an attempt to troll the game. Some people tried to offer a reasonable explanation for why Dark Souls wasn’t as popular and why people directly skipped to Elden Ring:

Advertisement

…or in some cases just don’t enjoy Dark Souls. I really didn’t enjoy the Demon’s Souls Remake either. Elden Ring takes the best parts from the previous games and rejects the nonsense, making Elden Ring objectively a better game. Or were you simply trolling?

Others were not amused and wanted to take digs at the original post author for trying to farm engagement and spread unnecessary negative emotion in the subreddit.

Why Elden Ring Was Made More Accessible Than Dark Souls

Elden Ring is one of the best titles released in the current decade.
Elden Ring is one of the best titles released in the current decade.

Even the series director, Miyazaki-san, talked about the game’s difficulty in an interview. In the interview, the director stated that, if talked about strictly as an action game, the game is much more forgiving than a traditional Dark Souls game.

Not to mention, the difficulty is subjective. In the post made by the Redditor that was subject to a lot of criticism, some players also mentioned that they found Dark Souls much easier than Elden Ring. The difference in difficulty, however, is very tangible between the two games. That is because the game is in a different genre as well.

Advertisement

It allows players to flee a losing battle, use spirit summons, and call companions to their aid in defeating challenging bosses. Despite petty attempts to hate a game that has taken the entire industry by storm, it shows no signs of stopping, especially with Shadow of the Erdtree‘s imminent launch.

Did you play Elden Ring? If yes, which boss battle did you find the most difficult? Let us know in the comment section below.

Follow us for more entertainment coverage on FacebookTwitterInstagram, and YouTube.

Advertisement

Avatar

Written by Sparsh Jaimini

Articles Published: 330

Sparsh Jaimini Sharma is a video games enthusiast and a Games Writer. A true white-blooded Madridsta. He is often seen grinding away at EAFC 24's Ultimate team and learning to code when he is not writing. A Batman fan and Arkham Games connoisseur. He is the quintessential DC aficionado.