“It got slaughtered”: Seinfeld Pilot Had Horrible Reviews and Yet NBC Put it Up Against One of the Most Beloved Tim Allen Sitcoms – The Rest is History

NBC stuck with the sitcom despite its initial less-than-stellar reception.

“It got slaughtered”: Seinfeld Pilot Had Horrible Reviews and Yet NBC Put it Up Against One of the Most Beloved Tim Allen Sitcoms – The Rest is History

SUMMARY

  • Similar to some other big NBC shows, Seinfeld was initially off to a rough start.
  • But despite its pilot being thrashed, NBC stuck with it, and the results eventually paid off.
  • NBC offered Jerry Seinfeld over $100M to return for more Seinfeld.
Show More
Featured Video

It isn’t uncommon for sitcoms to get off on the wrong foot and eventually find their footing along the line, and similar was the case for Larry David’s Seinfeld. Often regarded as one of the greatest sitcoms of all time, during its original run on NBC, the sitcom didn’t begin on a high note, as its pilot was completely different from what the show would become later on.

Advertisement

Similar to some of NBC’s other hit shows, which were too off to a rough start, the reception to Seinfeld‘s pilot was brutal, but the network decided to stick with it nevertheless.

Seinfeld Was off to a Bad Start but NBC Stuck With Jerry Seinfeld’s Vision

Seinfeld
Seinfeld (1989-1998) | NBC

NBC is no stranger to greenlighting shows that initially fumbled their beginning, with major examples being The Office and Cheers. However, things were even rougher in Sienfield‘s case, as the pilot was far from what the sitcom would eventually become, and the reviews from fans were mostly negative. While it’d have been optimal to cancel the show altogether, NBC stuck with it and would eventually secure funds to secure four more episodes by ditching one two-hour Bob Hope special.

Advertisement

While after that Larry David stressed that there were no more stories to tell, co-creator Jerry Seinfeld was hellbent on moving it forward, and 13 more episodes were ordered. Unfortunately, the show would get obliterated after going against Tim Allen’s Home Improvement.

Home Improvement | American Broadcasting Company
Home Improvement | American Broadcasting Company

Former NBC exec Warren Littlefield recalled (via Fox News):

“Larry David of course said, ‘I don’t have any  more stories to tell, Jerry turn the order down,’ and Jerry said, ‘No we’ll do 13 more episodes’ and we put it up against ‘Home Improvement’ and it got slaughtered,”

But despite the less-than-stellar results, the creators weren’t deterred as they loved what they were doing, and the network too would continue to back them.

Advertisement

Jerry Seinfeld Was Offered Over $100M to Return for Another Season

Despite initial hurdles, Seinfeld would eventually find its footing and go on to enjoy nine seasons, which fans keep on revisiting to this day. However, the execs at NBC wanted the series to continue past season 9 and offered Jerry Seinfeld over $100M  to return for another season.

Michael Richards as Cosmos Kramer in Seinfeld
Seinfeld | NBC

He explained:

“Over $100 million. We offered him $5 million an episode. We didn’t mess around. What we put on the table was unheard of. We went in there with a staggering sum and there was tremendous confidence that no one could walk away from it.”

But Littlefield recounted that the creator was initially tempted to accept the offer, but eventually walked away in order to focus on other aspects of life.

Advertisement

Seinfeld is available to stream on Netflix.

Avatar

Written by Santanu Roy

Articles Published: 1395

Santanu Roy is a film enthusiast with a deep love for the medium of animation while also being obsessed with The Everly Brothers, Billy Joel, and The Platters. Having expertise in everything related to Batman, Santanu spends most of his time watching and learning films, with Martin Scorsese and Park Chan-wook being his personal favorites. Apart from pursuing a degree in animation, he also possesses a deep fondness for narrative-driven games and is currently a writer at Fandomwire with over 1000 articles.