Monkey D. Garp stands out as one of the most complex and controversial characters in One Piece. Known as “Garp the Hero,” he is a Vice Admiral in the Marines whose legacy is connected with Gol D. Rogers. However, as a father and mentor, his role is often a topic of debate among fans, particularly in light of his relationships with his grandsons Luffy and Ace. On the other hand, his treatment of Koby and Helmeppo as their mentor brings out a different side of his personality.
Monkey D. Garp’s relentless discipline and tough love define his mentoring style. This can be seen by the fact that during Luffy and Ace’s early training, he regularly put them through difficult survival situations. However, the most compelling evidence of Garp’s impact as a mentor is seen in Koby’s character development. His transformation showcases Garp’s capability to see potential in even the most unlikely people and foster it.
The Misunderstood Aspect of Monkey D. Garp in One Piece
A meme has been shared recently by @DailyOPMemes on X (previously, Twitter), that portrays Monkey D. Garp’s favoritism towards Koby and Helmeppo. This joke also highlights Garp’s relationship dynamic with his grandsons, Luffy and Ace.
This post hilariously showcases Koby and Helmeppo as Garp’s favorite children, while Luffy and Ace are the “unwanted” ones. Many people agreed with the context depicted in the post.
Amidst the hilarious exchanges, a particular comment from @minkawerkz stood out, which unintentionally highlighted the often-overlooked aspects of Garp’s character and his profound impact as a mentor.
They needed him more than Luffy & Ace did!
This joke sheds light on an essential truth about Garp’s character, which is his dedication as a mentor that extends beyond his blood ties. While Luffy and Ace followed their own ways as pirates, Garp provided invaluable guidance and wisdom to Koby and the other Marines under his command.
Countless young Marines who look up to Garp as a role model have had their futures shaped by his mentoring, which has left a lasting legacy inside the Marine ranks. While some may view his mentorship methods as excessively brutal, it is important to recognize Garp’s intentions behind these actions.
Despite the controversy regarding his relationship dynamics with Luffy and Ace, Garp’s legacy as a father figure is marked by his unwavering commitment to his principles, his profound internal struggles, and the lasting impact he had on the lives of both.
Analysis of Garp’s Character as a Mentor and Grandfather
One of the most significant criticisms directed at Garp revolves around his role in the tragic death of Ace at Marineford. Many claim that Garp, as both a marine and Ace’s grandfather, failed to protect him. However, this viewpoint totally ignores the intense personal conflict he went through during the war. Even though he had a duty to follow the law as a Marine, he was horrified by Ace’s demise.
Koby’s character growth is one of the strongest arguments for Garp’s competence as a mentor. Koby was a timid and anxious cabin boy on Alvida’s ship when he was first introduced. But later he became a fearless and skilled Marine under Garp’s guidance, rising to the rank of captain. Beyond just physical training, Garp had a profound impact on Koby. He gave him a strong sense of justice and the bravery to speak up for his convictions.
In One Piece, Monkey D. Garp’s role as a mentor and parent is a multifaceted one. Despite the criticism he faces regarding his relationship with Luffy and Ace, and especially regarding Ace’s death, it is important to acknowledge the enduring impact he has had on characters like Koby. Though controversial, Garp’s tough love has proven to be an effective method of cultivating strength, resilience, and a sense of justice. In the end, Garp’s legacy as a mentor is evidence of his dedication to nurturing the next generation, whether they are blood-related or not.
You can watch One Piece on Crunchyroll.
