Would you believe that some of the most adored Marvel actors in the world were once considered for the enduring role of Bruce Wayne / Batman? Although Robert Pattinson, the latest Batman, and Ben Affleck made a lasting impression on the character, it is intriguing to consider what might have happened if some other Hollywood stars had donned the Batsuit.
The world loves Batman more than any other superhero. Adam West, Michael Keaton, Val Kilmer, George Clooney, Christian Bale, Ben Affleck, and a long list of other actors have all portrayed the Caped Crusader on film over the years. But, there were also Marvel stars who tried out for the superhero role but were unsuccessful.
Thus, here’s a list of five Marvel actors who were considered for the Batman role over the years.
Ethan Hawke
Warner Bros. had to find a replacement for Michael Keaton for Batman Forever (1995) after he declined the offer to play the title character in a third Batman movie. Ethan Hawke was offered the part by the producers, but he declined it out of concern that playing the Caped Crusader would result in typecasting.
According to Collider, Hawke later expressed regret over his decision because playing Batman would have greatly increased his career opportunities.
RELATED: Gwyneth Paltrow Won Ben Affleck’s Heart With One Kind Gesture After Their Painful Breakup
Jake Gyllenhaal
Jake Gyllenhaal’s edgiest roles from films like Donnie Darko and Nightcrawler are reminiscent of Robert Pattinson’s dark, brooding performance in The Batman. The actor was reportedly a candidate for the role of Bruce Wayne when Christopher Nolan was developing his ground-breaking reboot (The Dark Knight), according to CinemaBlend.
If Gyllenhaal had played Bruce in Nolan’s trilogy, he and Heath Ledger would have reunited for a much less endearing dynamic in The Dark Knight.
Pierce Brosnan
Pierce Brosnan was the leading candidate for the role of Bruce Wayne when Tim Burton’s first Batman film (1989) was in the planning stages. In contrast, as per The Guardian, Brosnan declined the role because he did not want to play a comic book character.
The lead role was eventually given to Michael Keaton, who won over the audience with his convincing portrayal of Bruce Wayne.
Nicholas Hoult
The casting directors typically cast as many candidates as they can find when casting a new Batman. But because Matt Reeves had a clear vision of the impressionable, young Bruce Wayne he wanted on screen, the only actors on the shortlist for the Batman role were Robert Pattinson and Nicholas Hoult.
Both actors allegedly appeared in an old Batsuit for their auditions, according to Collider. Previously, Hoult portrayed Hank McCoy / Beast in the X-Men films. Before deciding on Pattinson, Reeves, and Warner Bros. executives debated the two actors during the week following Memorial Day.
Willem Dafoe
When rumors began to circulate that Tim Burton had approached Willem Dafoe about playing the Joker in his first Batman movie, fans naturally assumed that he was a contender for the role. The actor, however, revealed to MTV News that he was in fact being considered for the role of Batman:
“Very early, they talked to me about playing Batman.”
Dafoe rose to prominence for his portrayal of the supervillain Norman Osborn / Green Goblin in MCU’s film Spider-Man (2002), a role he reprised in Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021).
Although none of these Marvel actors were ever cast as Batman, their potential casting exemplifies the range of talent that can be found in the superhero genre. We can not help but smile at the thought of these Marvel actors donning the Dark Knight’s cape and cowl, even if it is only in our imaginations.
Robert Pattinson eventually accepted the role in the last released superhero film, The Batman (2022). Additionally, The Batman – Part II’s production had already started by April 2022. The upcoming film is expected to be released on October 3, 2025.
Meanwhile, you can stream The Batman on Amazon Prime Video, Max, and DIRECTV.
