Chris Evans’ Greatest Captain America Scene Nearly Started a Marvel Civil War: “There was certainly a debate”

Chris Evans' portrayal of Captain America sparked a debate on how he could summon lightning with Mjolnir alone without Thor's help.

Chris Evans' Greatest Captain America Scene Nearly Started a Marvel Civil War: "There was certainly a debate"

SUMMARY

  • Captain America lifting Mjolnir was a grand moment but it was also caused a lot of debate within the franchise.
  • Although Thor: Ragnarok established Thor of wielding thunder without a hammer, questions were raised about Captain America's ability to summon lightning with the hammer.
  • Christopher Markus confirmed that this had been an ongoing debate since 2015, meaning that they had been planning for this moment for many years.
Show More
Featured Video

Avengers: Endgame was one of the greatest superhero films fans have seen and it held Chris Evans’ Captain America in high regard as well. It was an emotional ride of ups and downs that manipulated the fans’ reactions to the events that were foregoing in the film. From the roaring cheers to the somber silence, there were all sorts of emotions swimming in theatres.

Advertisement
Chris Evans
Chris Evans as Captain America

When people watched the film for the first time, it was a spectacle to behold. The visuals it offered, the long-awaited reunions it finally gave the audience, and most importantly, it did justice to several characters. One scene in particular had the audience screaming because of how long they had waited for it. Captain America lifting Mjolnir was a grand moment. However, it was also one that caused a lot of debate within the franchise.

Also Read: Chris Hemsworth, Tom Hiddleston Reunion Not Happening: Loki Writer Gives Heartbreaking Season 3 Update

Advertisement

Thor’s Rebranding Did Not Come Without Overall Issues

Before Taika Waititi took over the Thor franchise, Chris Hemsworth’s character was a much different person than what the fans are now used to seeing him as. He has a comedic side, he is more human in ways that separate him from humanity than anything else. MCU: The Reign of Marvel Studios describes him as a ‘self-absorbed and absurd yet still a virtuous hero.’

Chris Hemsworth as Thor with his Mjölnir
Chris Hemsworth as Thor with his Mjölnir

His journey in Thor: Ragnarok came with a certain sense of issues for the overall franchise. The MCU was met with continuity errors that they were somehow made to manage. In fact, Stephen McFeely and Christopher Markus were forced to change aspects of Avengers: Endgame and Infinity War to accommodate these new ideas. However, another obstacle in their path was Steve Rogers’ most iconic scene.

Also Read: Chris Evans’ Absence Hits Captain America: Brave New World Hard – Abysmal Test Scores Lead to 6 More Months of Reshoot, Delayed till 2025

Advertisement

Chris Evans’ Captain America’s Most Important Scene Became Difficult to Execute

Avengers: Endgame comes full circle with a sequence that was hinted at as early as Avengers: Age of Ultron. Steve Rogers’ being worthy of lifting Mjolnir has been something fans have been waiting to see for years. Although, Thor: Ragnarok established Chris Hemsworth’s hero to be the God of Lightning, capable of wielding thunder despite his access to the hammer in particular. So the question they came to face was, why would Chris Evans’ Captain America be able to summon lightning with the hammer alone?

The moment when Steve Rogers wields Mjolnir, Thor's entranced hammer in Avengers Endgame
The moment when Steve Rogers wields Mjolnir, Thor’s entranced hammer in Avengers Endgame

“There was certainly a debate at one point because particularly in Ragnarok, it establishes that Thor can summon the lightning without the hammer. I think Odin even says, ‘It was never the hammer.’ And yet Cap summons the lightning with the hammer. You get to those things and you’re like, ‘It’s too awesome not to do it! We’ll talk about it later.'”

Christopher Markus, in MCU: The Reign of Marvel Studios, confirmed that this had been an ongoing debate since 2015, meaning that they had been planning for this moment for many years. The decision in the end was to just let the sequence be as is, and have it be dealt with in future scenes or movies. If any more thought was put into the scene of Steve Rogers lifting Mjolnir, then it could easily ruin the massive significance it otherwise had.

Also Read: Chris Evans Almost Said ‘Avengers Assemble!’ 4 Years Before Endgame in $1.4B Movie

Advertisement
Adya Godboley

Written by Adya Godboley

Articles Published: 1446

An avid writer fluent in everything Marvel, Adya Godboley is an Assistant Content Lead for FandomWire. She has rich experience in critically analyzing all that is said in between the lines. Hopelessly obsessed with Greek Mythology, she is currently pursuing her Bachelor of Arts in English. Adya has written over 1300 articles on various topics expressing her passion and love for all things entertainment.