“Current fans’ concept of ‘quality’ confuses me”: One Piece Artist Defended Shoddy Animation, Cited DBZ and Berserk as Examples

In May 2022, animator Henry Thurlow initiated a discussion on Twitter regarding One Piece episode 1018. He engaged with disappointed fans who were not satisfied with the episode.

"Current fans' concept of 'quality' confuses me": One Piece Artist Defended Shoddy Animation, Cited DBZ and Berserk as Examples

SUMMARY

  • Henry Thurlow, a key animator for One Piece, shared worries in a post about fans not enjoying the animation quality.
  • While acknowledging the significance of good animation to fans, he emphasized that the story holds greater importance than animation quality.
  • Thurlow defended instances of lower-quality animation by citing examples of older animes such as DBZ and Berserk.
Show More
Featured Video

One Piece is the best anime right now because of Eiichiro Oda’s great storytelling and creativity. The current animated fight scenes are excellent, but it wasn’t always like this. In the past, One Piece didn’t have the best animation quality, and some people didn’t watch because of it.

Advertisement
One Piece
One Piece

Henry Thurlow, a key animator for One Piece, expressed concern in a post about fans not liking the animation quality.

Advertisement

As a fan, he understands that animation quality is important to viewers. However, the artist thought that the story was much more important than the animation quality and defended instances of lower-quality animation giving examples like DBZ and Berserk.

Also Read: One Piece: A Forgotten Marineford Scene Casts Doubt on Shanks’ True Allegiance as Yonko Sets Out to Find the One Piece

Advertisement

One Piece Animator Concerned About The Fans’ Choice

In May 2022, animator Henry Thurlow started a conversation on Twitter (reported by ComicBook) about One Piece episode 1018. He talked to disappointed fans who were let down by the episode.

Henry Thurlow
Henry Thurlow

Some fans expected this because episodes 1016 and 1017 had impressive animation. When animation enthusiasts criticized One Piece, Thurlow responded with the following:

Advertisement

“I wonder what the people who complain every week about TV anime think about older series, the ones I grew up loving. DBZ, Yuyu Hakusho, Hokuto no Ken, Berserk, Kenshin, etc. They rarely had “insane/smooth” animation. Just great art, great characters & story, & were perfect as is. As someone who’s watched anime probably every day since middle school & then dedicated my life to it, Current fans’ concept of “quality” confuses me. Older series had better art & less animation I think, but the old OVA’s blow everything current out of the water.”

He wonders if people who complain about today’s TV anime ever consider the older series, like DBZ, Yuyu Hakusho, Hokuto no Ken, Berserk, etc., that he loved growing up. Those shows may not have had super-smooth animation, but they had great art, characters, and stories, and they were perfect as they were.

He believes that while animation quality is crucial for making an anime captivating, the most important element of a show is its story.

Advertisement

Also Read: “There is no problem”: Eiichiro Oda Tries to Assure One Piece Fans After Revealing a Major Health Scare That’s Left Everyone Concerned

The Animator also Hinted at the Animation Quality of Wano Arc Long Before its Release

The animator, Thurlow also responded to specific criticisms about episode 1018. Some fans were unhappy with how energy auras were used, and their complaints were quickly countered. The artist shared:

Advertisement

Yup that was me. And Imma do it again and again and again literally for years. And just cause I know you don’t like it, I’m gonna make it an even bigger aura next time. Blue and red flames all at once, multiple layers going at the same time. Can’t wait. After this thread what I’m gonna do is try to make the biggest aura *ever* in anime. Like Gon’s hair from HXH kinda aura. Gonna add some filler too of Enel on the moon looking down saying ‘Wow that aura’s coming close to me!'”

One Piece Wano arc visual
One Piece

The artist said that because fans don’t like it, they’ll make an even bigger and more impressive aura next time. It will have blue and red flames and multiple layers which they really did in the Wano arc, which is considered the best-animated arc in the series.

Also Read: One Piece Theory: Buggy’s True Devil Fruit Ability is Nuclear Fission, Can Beat Luffy

Advertisement
Avatar

Written by Tanmay Jha

Tanmay writes about anime for FandomWire. He's currently pursuing a Bachelor's degree in Journalism and Mass Communication. With a passion for animation and graphics, he has authored over 240 articles on anime, sharing insights and reviews with fellow fans, seamlessly combining his love for animation with journalism.